While Anchorage might be better known for our fresh Alaskan seafood, hearty steakhouses, and endless salmon options, our Italian restaurants are way better than we get credit for. And this guide is here to prove it. From a cozy trattoria where the Chianti flows like tap water to a downtown spot serving bottomless pasta under rustic chandeliers, these are the very best Italian restaurants in Anchorage.
Little Italy
$$ | (907) 344-1515 | WEBSITE
Whoever said that Italian food needs to be fancy to be memorable was almost certainly talking about Little Italy, a cozy neighborhood spot tucked away off Abbott. As the name suggests, Little Italy doesn’t miss in the traditional favorites department—the pizza is crisp and satisfying, the baked meatballs in sauce are rich and tender, and the garlic bread soaks up every last drop—but the main reason we’d send you to this hidden gem is their perfectly balanced eggplant parmigiana with penne pasta.
Get a plate alongside house-made croutons and a slice of not-too-sweet tiramisu with fresh-brewed coffee for a comforting meal that’ll have you feeling like you just discovered your new go-to spot for family dinners.
Ghost Kitchen
$ | (907) 339-1530 | WEBSITE
The name of this culinary destination in Anchorage might leave you with questions. Such as, what exactly is a ghost kitchen and why does it serve both Korean chicken and Italian pasta? Ghost Kitchen—a reference to its diverse, almost spectral menu—is the kind of place where you can satisfy multiple cravings in one visit. The specialty here is pasta, and though the offerings span continents, the Rose with Chicken and Shrimp Alfredo is nothing short of incredible.
The creamy sauce clings to each noodle, and the shrimp are plump and sweet. Skip the hesitation and double up on their garlic bread, which arrives hot and buttery. And, if you somehow have room for more indulgence, get the K-rolls, made with lots of crunchy, savory filling. At around $15–$20 a plate, it’s a steal for food this good. The space is simple and modern, with warm lighting that makes you want to linger over your meal.
Sure, there was that one cashier who seemed off, but the rest of the staff are so genuinely friendly that you’ll forget all about it. Honestly, the hardest part is choosing what to order—everything is loved!
Fletcher’s
$$ | (907) 343-2218 | WEBSITE
This classy Italian spot in Anchorage is our go-to for a special meal with a small group. The atmosphere is relaxing, the service is attentive, and the dining room has just the right amount of elegance for a memorable evening. Aside from perfectly seared halibut and delicious chopped salad, Fletcher’s is home to the best baked Alaska in town.
For around $30 per person—with a minimum of two people—these delightful desserts are served with a lovely presentation that makes them worth saving room for. If you take that route, Fletcher’s lets you choose between unique drinks like NA liquor and espresso martinis—options range from classy cocktails to perfectly paired beverages that complement the meal beautifully.
Sicily’s Pizza Muldoon
$$ | (907) 333-8000 | WEBSITE
Sicily’s Pizza Muldoon started as a local pizza spot, but has become a reliable favorite in Anchorage. The straightforward, order-at-the-phone counter operation can sometimes mean one person juggling everything, creating a brief wait, but if you’re picking up for family or friends, the food will definitely be worth it.
The menu focuses mainly on solid, no-fuss pizzas like the medium stuffed crust pepperoni with sausage, spinach, bell peppers, olives, and tomatoes, but don’t skip the chance to customize your own pie. It’s a hearty, satisfying meal made with care, ensuring even small orders feel special. If you’re here with a group of three to four, share a couple of large pizzas, which come piping hot with fresh toppings and that perfectly baked crust for around $50. Leftovers will be a guarantee.
Sicily’s Pizza Northern Lights
$$ | (907) 333-8000 | WEBSITE
A pizza delivery no longer arrives as quickly as it used to, but at Sicily’s Pizza Northern Lights, a local Italian spot known for its takeout, it still happens in record time. Most pies here are around $15 for a medium, which you can enjoy fresh from the oven or have delivered to your door. The classic Chicken Garlic pizza is great, but it’s the sub sandwiches where things get really satisfying.
The calzones are stuffed and hearty, and the gyros and wings are full of flavor, especially after being paired with the house sauces. Once you’ve placed your order (plus drinks and sides), settle in at one of the cozy booths where you’ll join regulars enjoying one of the most reliable pizza parties in town.
Sicily’s Pizza Dimond
$ | (907) 333-8000 | WEBSITE
Serving classic Italian-American pizza with a straightforward approach, Sicily’s Pizza Dimond stands out not just on this list, but from pretty much anywhere in the neighborhood. The pizza options, like the well-liked vegetarian garlic pizza with artichoke, tomatoes, and mushrooms, are all decent. But nothing compares to their pepperoni pizza, made with a flavorful distribution of toppings and a satisfying crust.
The best way to sample the offerings at Sicily’s Pizza Dimond is their standard large pie, a reliable choice that includes a solid pizza for around $18. It’s such a straightforward meal, we immediately imagined ourselves grabbing a slice here occasionally in one of their simple booths watching the local news on the small TV in the corner.
Originale
$ | (907) 868-7900 | WEBSITE
If you’ve never fallen for a sandwich, you will after trying anything at Originale, whether it’s the muffaletta packed with expertly crafted meats and cheeses or the Nonni sammie with its perfectly married flavors. The restaurant’s bread and pinsa dough are always fresh made in-house with high-quality ingredients, but the story really starts with the fast service and friendly staff who make you feel like you’re at your nonna’s house.
These days, this counter-service spot is run by a warm, welcoming team who usually stands ready to chat and make guests feel comfortable. Originale’s front counter is lined with fresh sandwiches, plus they’ve got a solid menu of sides and desserts—grab some potato salad and a whole cannoli in one go.
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
$$ | (907) 333-1300 | WEBSITE
From the moment you walk into Olive Garden, you’re at the center of a family-friendly feast. That might sound predictable on paper, but this welcoming Italian restaurant in the shopping center has created a space where everyone is allowed to relax, eat satisfying food, and stay as long as they like. The menu focuses primarily on classic Italian-American dishes like the Tour of Italy entree, but the star of the show is without question the friendly service.
The skilled mixologists and attentive staff provide a genuine, caring atmosphere, with a slight warmth that makes you want to return. Olive Garden usually gets busy during prime dinner hours, so although you can probably snag a walk-in spot with plenty of parking, you should consider booking ahead for one of the kid-friendly tables with games.
Las Margaritas
$$ | (907) 349-4922 | WEBSITE
Las Margaritas in Anchorage is known for its unique Mexican-Italian fusion, or more accurately, the way it seamlessly blends margaritas with Mediterranean flavors. There’s a cucumber jalapeño margarita for $12 that’s become a local favorite, as well as delicious Pina Colada mocktails for $8, both of which pair perfectly with the restaurant’s signature chips and excellent salsa. Unless you want to miss out on the best dishes, plan on trying the halibut tacos and shredded beef enchiladas.
The good news is that Las Margaritas offers a comfortable, roomy setting the rest of the evening, and the food is tasty enough that even your most particular dining companion won’t mind the occasional inconsistency. Get the Gloria salad, fluffy rice, and beans that aren’t pasty—all of which come in generous, satisfying portions.
Guido’s Pizza
$ | (907) 563-2222 | WEBSITE
Guido’s Pizza is a long-standing Italian favorite in Anchorage that’s a great place to grab a slice or a whole pie. That said, it’s their consistently delicious menu that’s a sight to behold. Around lunch and dinner, groups of all sizes fill the welcoming space, drawn by the attentive staff and amazing prices that don’t overcharge like many places do today.
The menu stays reliably satisfying, but we always keep an eye out for the gluten-free cauliflower pizza that one reviewer called the best they’ve ever had, the garlic parmesan wings with their crunchy texture and well-seasoned flavor, and the Guido Special pizza with its thick hand-tossed crust and ample toppings of pepperoni, sausage, black olives, and mushrooms. Drop by for a quick meal, grab a seat amid the charming variety of items hanging on the walls, and lay out your Guido’s Pizza bounty.
Pizza Plaza
$$ | (907) 274-1735 | WEBSITE
Half-cozy restaurant, half-takeout haven, this Anchorage spot is your reliable choice for fresh Italian dishes, generous portions and family-like service. Their food is prepared fresh and packaged well for takeout, with highlights like the spaghetti with meat sauce and marinara—a generous portion for about $18. Plus, there’s a particularly excellent black olive pizza here—a simple yet delicious option with a tasty crust and tangy sauce that’s sold by the whole pie. Get one (or two) of them.
Flattop Pizza + Pasta
$ | (907) 677-7665 | WEBSITE
This Anchorage pizza joint has been serving up hot, fresh pies with that friendly local vibe for years. So naturally, it’s got that classic pub atmosphere—vintage tunes playing, cold beers on tap, and plenty of space to spread out for game nights. You can stop by for a tasty chicken parmesan hoagie or those spicy cheese sticks, but most come here for the pizza classics like the wild mushroom or the loaded meat pie.
We especially love the big kahuna pizza with its fantastic sauce, amazing flavors, and that perfect non-greasy crust. Flattop Pizza + Pasta also offers those delicious sausage and pepper heroes and ginger beer highlights that keep the regulars coming back. The Caesar salad could use some work, but with very reasonable prices and that welcoming staff, it’s a great spot for a chill evening.
Eat’alia
$ | (907) 339-1530 | WEBSITE
This fast-casual Italian spot in Anchorage has the atmosphere of a no-frills takeout counter. And while ordering through DoorDash may be the initial convenience, you haven’t truly experienced Eat’alia until you’ve sampled their food. From menu staples like beef pasta and shrimp alfredo to flavorful dishes like shrimp pesto, Eat’alia’s offerings are full of hits. Whether you come to Eat’alia on a busy weeknight or just a random lunch break, get their shrimp alfredo.
It comes out perfectly portioned in a generous takeout container with more than enough creamy sauce and tender shrimp to satisfy.