Ever found yourself craving Italian in Tulsa and settling for ‘pretty good’? Of course not. Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, you deserve the absolute best—the kind that makes you close your eyes and sigh. That’s why we’ve scoured the city to bring you this definitive list of the top Italian spots, updated for 2025.
Bria’s Italian Ice and Ice Cream
$ | (918) 876-0552 | WEBSITE
Taking kids for dessert shouldn’t feel like a chore, but sometimes it does. It’s like trying to find shade in the middle of a desert. Yet not only will we drive across town to Bria’s Italian Ice and Ice Cream, we’ll happily watch our children play in that back room while we enjoy our treats. Bria’s makes us do sensible things, because Bria’s serves some of the most refreshing desserts in the city.
Their Italian ice is authentic, smooth, and just a little bit tart, and it maintains perfect texture while delivering flavors like watermelon and salted caramel. This is simple dessert made exceedingly well, and it’s greater than the sum of its parts. The root beer float might be even better. Show up ready to relax, and be grateful for the opportunity to let your kids play at this family-friendly Tulsa institution. Bring some friends.
This place offers party rentals, which is yet another reason why we’ll do practical things to enjoy dessert here.
Carrabba’s Italian Grill
$$ | (918) 254-8888 | WEBSITE
This Tulsa Italian spot has been serving since 1986, and is—after a recent refresh from the corporate team—way more inviting than that makes it sound. This place always had the makings of a reliable, family-friendly dinner: attentive service, accommodating staff (like the personable Hunter and Ali), and a welcoming atmosphere with nice background music. Now, it also has the food to match.
You’ll face some delicious choices between things like the perfectly cooked Sirloin, the lovely Lasagna, and various vegetarian options that cater to different needs. You can’t really go wrong, though you’ll appreciate your server’s warm and knowledgeable guidance through the menu. Carrabba’s is the first place we’d recommend for a satisfying, no-fuss family meal—or even better, a group gathering, so you can sample more dishes.
Always finish your visit with the fresh, hot desserts that round out the experience.
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
$ | (918) 254-0082 | WEBSITE
This family-friendly Italian restaurant is going to satisfy you, but not with truffles, foie gras, or starched linen napkins. There’s none of that here. Only Italian-American classics served generously on plates that are delivered from the kitchen by servers in matching aprons. Praised for years for their exceptional handling of food allergies, Olive Garden is the best at what it does: comforting food you crave the moment you walk out the door.
You’ll particularly remember the crisp and tangy signature salad, Seafood Alfredo swimming in creamy sauce, and the overall feeling of being cared for by a kind and fun crew. In the cozy, wheelchair-accessible dining room where families gather under warm lighting like they’re at a Sunday supper, everything feels like a highlight.
Dalesandro’s
$$ | (918) 582-1551 | WEBSITE
Dalesandro’s bills itself as one of Tulsa’s best Italian spots, and true to form, you’ll find beef carpaccio, swordfish piccata, and freshly baked bread here. But the place is less rustic trattoria, more intimate hideaway—like Italy took a cozy corner booth and settled down in Oklahoma.
The hearty, satisfying, comfort-forward dishes shine consistently, but their three staples should always be on your table: the incredible vegan mushroom risotto paired with crunchy sourdough toast and garlic spread, that standout swordfish piccata, and a bowl called simply “Brodo.” It’s a warm, savory broth that tastes like home and hospitality. Don’t even get us started on the delicious cocktails, or the friendly owners Saul and Angie who create that welcoming atmosphere.
Mazzio’s Pizza & Wings
$ | (918) 664-4444 | WEBSITE
Long waits are the worst, and no matter how good that pizza, wing, or salad spin-off is, we’ll hardly ever tell you to endure one. Mazzio’s Pizza & Wings is the exception. Inside this Tulsa spot propped up with a wheelchair ramp, a single server manages the city’s most reliable pizza with a steady hand. The crust crunches like fresh breadsticks, and the cheese stretches for days. To get your own box full of the stuff, you’re going to have to wait—at least twenty minutes, and probably more.
The staff takes their time, chatting up regulars, handing out extra napkins, and keeping the salad bar gleaming under bright lights. It’s a lengthy process, but once you come face to face with that tray of supreme pizza, all grievances melt away.
Jay’s Original Hoagies
$ | (918) 488-8866 | WEBSITE
Jay’s Original Hoagies entered the sandwich scene fully formed, but don’t call it just another deli (though they do have exactly 12 inches of satisfaction in their famous Italian Special). The sandwiches at this Tulsa spot are exceptional—from the moment we tasted the creamy Italian dressing on their fully loaded hoagie, we were on board.
The menu is extensive, but full of delightful surprises, like chicken salad hiding under a cap of banana peppers, or ghost pepper cheese that actually packs a little kick. Watch from your seat at their bright, warm counter as Jay and Rob pluck fresh vegetables off the line, pull hot bread out of the oven, and wrangle massive portions of deli meat. In keeping with Jay’s friendly, community spirit, most seats are reserved for walk-ins, so the earlier you skip out of work to arrive, the better.
Villa Ravenna Fine Dining
$$$ | (918) 270-2666 | WEBSITE
Sometimes, you want to go somewhere intimate and inviting, where you can wear something comfortable and see someone who genuinely cares about your evening. It’s a natural instinct. Don’t fight it. When it’s that kind of night, your best option is Villa Ravenna. From dedicated owners who ensure every guest feels welcome, this cozy restaurant is a heartfelt production with warm lighting, rustic wooden tables, and servers dressed for a friendly neighborhood gathering.
It’s the sort of place where you’d expect service to be an afterthought, but every section of the Italian menu is filled with highlights. Start with the pear and avocado salad that’s infinitely more satisfying than it sounds, and follow that up with the standout Alfredo dishes and Vitelo Alla Parmigiano.
Biga
$$ | (918) 743-2442 | WEBSITE
Sometimes, we’re wrong. It’s rare, but it happens. Our initial impression of Biga, for example, was pretty lukewarm. But that was a while back, a confusing time when avocado toast was the breakfast du jour and everyone was obsessed with artisanal pickles. With its perfect mix of calm, relaxing atmosphere and excellent, unfussy food, this Tulsa restaurant has grown on us immensely over the years.
It’s one of our favorite Italian spots in Oklahoma, slightly edging out some of the flashier newcomers, so swing by for some wonderful bruschetta and a fresh, delicious tiramisu. Just be sure to take advantage of their great value option. Biga offers a set price for an appetizer, entree, and dessert, and we aren’t the only ones who appreciate this comfortable setting.
Prossimo Ristorante
$$ | (918) 271-5096 | WEBSITE
Like a slice of Little Italy transplanted straight into the heart of Tulsa, Prossimo Ristorante glows with warm amber lighting and rustic wood accents, plays Sinatra and Dean Martin, and serves the most authentic Italian food we’ve tasted outside of New York City, ever. You’ll have just as much fun watching the tableside mozzarella being made as you will savoring all the menu’s nods to Italian classics, from the beet carpaccio to the Caesar salad.
You’ll even find a tribute to the pork chop that regulars rave about. We’re especially fond of the pasta in the cheese wheel, served tableside—an invitation to indulge in pure decadence. Prossimo is one of the most sought-after reservations in town, but for a restaurant that feels like a culinary journey to Italy, it’s well worth it. Ask about the tableside alfredo.
Mondo’s Ristorante Italian
$$ | (918) 561-6300 | WEBSITE
Mondo’s Ristorante Italian in Brookside is so warm, and so fun, that you could easily bump someone’s chianti as you pass through the bustling front door. The number of diners packed inside, eagerly sharing garlic bread, is a testament to the generous portions coming out of Mondo’s open kitchen at the back. Virtually everything is elevated with authentic flavor, like thick eggplant Parmesan, or a cheese pizza crowned with fresh basil.
There’s a magnetic pull to these rustic dishes, and the wide variety of menu items just adds to the anticipation of every new visit. At Mondo’s, the team behind the friendly service cooks what they want, how they want—and everyone, us included, wants to be in on their dinner plans.
The Krazy Olive
$ | (918) 802-5275 | WEBSITE
There’s always a crowd inside The Krazy Olive (and sometimes spilling out the door too), packed with regulars who come to this Tulsa spot faithfully: for gyros piled high with tender meat and tangy tzatziki, or an overstuffed Italian sausage sandwich on fresh-baked bread, or hummus so creamy and rich it deserves its own fan club.
The staff behind the counter move with purpose, taking orders, checking on dietary needs, and pausing only to ask if you’d like extra pita with that meatball sub, or to let the kitchen know the Mediterranean salad is running low. Expect to leave in about 25 minutes—a warm pita clutched in one hand, and a takeout bag heavy enough to feed a small family in the other. All you’ll need to do next is find the nearest table, and dig in.
Napa Flats Wood-Fired Kitchen
$$ | (918) 948-6505 | WEBSITE
Living in Tulsa can feel predictable, and sometimes you crave an escape. When you need a reminder of why dining out still thrills, head to Napa Flats Wood-Fired Kitchen. Tucked away in a relaxed yet upscale setting, this Californian Italian spot serves soul-warming, wood-fired food, in an atmosphere that feels like a cozy retreat. Even the patio lighting is strangely inviting.
Eat some reassuringly tender braised beef ravioli, wood-fired pizza with the perfect char, a plate of garlic mashed potatoes so creamy they could probably cure a bad day, and a filet with shrimp that has us looking up synonyms for the word “flawless.” Bring a date, and an appetite so you can try as much as possible. The scent of smoky pizza crust will linger with you for hours after—a souvenir of one of the best meals you’ve had in recent memory.
Ti Amo Ristorante Italiano Downtown
$$ | (918) 592-5151 | WEBSITE
You could make the argument that downtown Italian spots are predictable and tired. And that would be a pretty compelling argument, if it weren’t for Ti Amo Ristorante Italiano Downtown. This downtown institution, which has been a Tulsa classic for years now, is a well-oiled machine that’s been fine-tuned to perfection. The service here skews north of impeccable, and the charming dining room’s soft lighting hits exactly where your plate goes.
But the actual glamor of this restaurant—and the main reason why it’s still an amazing place to eat—comes via the Italian classics. Picatta Di Pollo with a bright lemon caper sauce, fettuccine in a rich and creamy alfredo with gorgonzola that tastes like Rome, flaky and tender crab cakes—you book a reservation at Ti Amo primarily to get your hands on these.
Hideaway Pizza
$ | (918) 582-4777 | WEBSITE
Those who don’t eat vegetables, avert your eyes. Every edible surface at this Tulsa pizza spot is covered in a generous layer of fresh vegetables—and that’s exactly why we love it. From the same team that delivers top notch service and amazing food, this kid-friendly restaurant serves every kind of veggie pizza, from the veggie section to Build Your Own with various vegetables. The Extreme Pizza, which includes all the toppings combined on a freshly baked crust, is mandatory.
Follow that up with a survey course of Hideaway’s other offerings to find out just how many different textures come from a single vegetable medley: crisp peppers that eat like crunchy flavor bursts, mushrooms that’re tender but with a little bite, and caramelized onions. It’s educational, yes, but also delicious. Everything tastes even better when eaten at a table with coloring sheets while the great music plays.
Mazzio’s Italian Eatery
$ | (918) 664-4444 | WEBSITE
Settling into a cozy booth at Mazzio’s Italian Eatery, it’s easy to feel right at home with all the comforting flavors on your plate. Like the atmosphere, the Italian food here is straightforward and satisfying—from the cheese dippers with pepperoni that arrive bubbling hot to the perfectly hearty 4 meat calzones. Creamy, spicy notes mingle with grilled chicken and jalapeño Alfredo pizza, crispy boneless buffalo wings, and generous slices from the lunch buffet.
Plates of different dipping sauces, like the classic marinara and zesty ranch, tie individual bites together in mouthful after satisfying mouthful. Visit often—the buffet shifts with the day. On weekdays, you can load up at noon, piling your plate with pizza slices, wings, and more. On Tuesday evenings, gather inside surrounded by cheerful chatter and the steady warmth of the buffet line, or a table laden with calzones and dippers for the whole group.
il seme
$$ | (539) 525-0265 | WEBSITE
Between the bustling downtown spots and the casual trattorias, Il Seme stands out as a true gem in Tulsa’s Italian dining scene. We’ve tried many, but this is the shining star. This restaurant offers Italian classics typically made in home kitchens, and they do so in a cozy space with quintessential Tulsa warmth. Highlights include the rich ragu and homemade gnocchi that tastes like comfort even though it’s elegantly presented.
No meal at Il Seme would be quite right, however, without a few of the standout dishes that are harder to find elsewhere. Try the steak topped with seasonal herbs, and don’t miss the dessert balls. If you want to go big, share the deep-fried olives and meatballs special.
Andolini’s Pizzeria Cherry Street
$ | (918) 728-6111 | WEBSITE
People like to say that certain pizzerias feel like a slice of New York. But unless those people are talking about Andolini’s Pizzeria Cherry Street—a lively Italian spot in Tulsa’s classic old stretch—we don’t really believe them.
Inside the inviting space on Cherry Street, families and friends gather at wooden tables, watching kids burn off energy at the playground out back while waiting for some of the city’s best pizza, served by staff who will help you to your car before you even try their BBQ chicken pie. Bring the family, get a pitcher of local craft beer, and then move on to the outstanding vegetarian options, deliciously made in-house dough, and perfect BBQ sauce.
On your way out, the accommodating team might wave goodbye, and you won’t hesitate to wave right back.
Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza
$ | (918) 728-7326 | WEBSITE
A single slice of the Margherita and you know there’s magic happening inside this wood-fired oven in Tulsa. Upper Crust’s signature pizza is what might happen if Neapolitan tradition and American comfort food spent a summer in Italy together: a blistered, chewy crust topped with bright tomato sauce and milky fresh mozzarella. But the rest of the menu is full of quiet stars.
The Kitchen Sink pizza, loaded with just the right balance of toppings, and finished with a drizzle of olive oil, is one of our favorite hearty pies. The lightly fried mozzarella rounds are another perfectly executed starter, with creamy cheese within the golden breading. This relaxed-but-excellent restaurant consistently draws crowds for its lunch special, and we couldn’t be more satisfied.
Gambill’s Pastaria & Grocery | Fresh Pasta and Scratch Kitchen
$ | (918) 619-6645 | WEBSITE
Gambill’s is an extremely reliable restaurant. But not in a boring way. In a comforting way. At this Italian pasta spot in Tulsa, you can eat a plate of fettuccine pesto Alfredo, and know that it tastes this fresh every single day. And as long as you show up during non-peak hours, or don’t mind the loud music from that single large speaker, you can enjoy those generous portions whenever you want.
You can also share the perfect bread and mozzarella sticks, an Italian sausage-topped pasta, and ricotta balls drenched in sauce with friends, along with a steady stream of drinks. Sit in the clean dining area with its red crossed stripes on white walls, at one of the very clean tables, or just grab some gelato to go—and always, always finish with their delicious tiramisu.