It’s that time when Anchorage’s pizza joints try to lure locals out of their cozy winter hideouts, and into the warmth of their wood-fired ovens. This list is here. If you’re wondering what makes the cut, it’s where these pizzerias serve up everything from classic Neapolitan to inventive Alaskan-inspired pies, all vetted for 2025.
Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza
$ | (907) 222-6260 | WEBSITE
Almost everything we just said about traditional pizza joints applies to this take-and-bake spot. Except you’re not eating it there, some of the more complex topping combinations are off-limits, and the whole pizza is around $20. Other than that, you get to pick from the whole menu. Papa Murphy’s is all about pizza (we like the vegetarian options when made correctly) but there are meat choices too, so you can make this a fully loaded thing.
Great Alaska Pizza Company
$ | (907) 770-3733 | WEBSITE
Great Alaska Pizza Company is one of our favorite pizza spots in Anchorage, thanks to its fair price point. They drop their prices even lower for special deals, with a medium cheese or pepperoni pizza for just $5.99 on the last Tuesday of the month that includes their well-liked Italian bread. The quality of the ingredients is stellar, the toppings are generous, and if you’ve always wanted a quick, affordable, and satisfying pizza experience, start here.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (907) 258-3030 | WEBSITE
If you’ve never tried Domino’s surprisingly delicious marbled brownie, now is the time. We appreciate that the pizza chain kept its greatest hit among its affordable online deals. Order that and their stuffed breadsticks. The Parmesan bites are also spectacular and satisfy like a full appetizer, but you’ll have to pay a $3 upcharge for extra dipping sauce. It’s also $2 extra for their specialty crusts, so we’d go with the classic hand-tossed or thin crust instead.
Ski & Benny Pizza
$ | (907) 274-1114 | WEBSITE
We can’t think of a better time to visit Ski & Benny Pizza. Anchorage is less crowded in the winter, the restaurant isn’t packed with tourists, and (thanks to their generous portions) a pizza, wings, and a drink will cost you around $35 instead of what you’d pay at fancier spots. For your main, get the pizza (it’s our favorite dish). The Philly cheesesteak is a great alternative choice, and we love their fresh chicken parmesan.
Moose’s Tooth Pub & Pizzeria
$$ | (907) 258-2537 | WEBSITE
Moose’s Tooth is the sibling establishment to Broken Tooth Brewing, and its monthly special pizzas are also confusingly good. For dinner, the large pizza with half-and-half option includes classics like the Fire House, Brewhouse Favorite, and a “chef’s surprise” (lunch is basically the same, except no surprise and one less topping). You won’t have to worry about using your inside voice here.
The casual pub is decorated with rustic Alaskan memorabilia and bumps a playlist full of classic rock hits.
Sicily’s Pizza Dimond
$ | (907) 333-8000 | WEBSITE
What can you expect to eat at this pizza spot in Anchorage? That’s a great question that we can never really answer. The quality here seems to vary on a weekly (sometimes daily) basis. But it will include decent pizza options, including a well-liked vegetarian garlic pizza with good distribution of toppings like artichoke, tomatoes, and mushrooms. The garlic pizza makes a solid choice, and we enjoy all the pizzas (but especially the pepperoni pizza).
Amore’s Pizza
$ | (907) 333-2373 | WEBSITE
You can try Amore’s best classics in Anchorage this year, including their New York-style pizza with fantastic dough and solid cheese-to-sauce balance, and the popular Pepperoni and Pineapple pizza. For other options, they’re doing what they do best: serving consistently high-quality products. There’s the delicious Hawaiian pizza with perfect chewiness, tasty wings prepared with care. Plus, their standout crust with great flavor is what’s for the main event.
Pizza Plaza
$$ | (907) 274-1735 | WEBSITE
Pizza Plaza’s spaghetti with meat sauce is usually $18 and includes a generous portion with dinner salad and garlic bread. Prioritize that dish. For pizza, their black olive option (normally $22) and shrimp Milano ($26) are both available as complete meals. Get those and the alfredo pasta for a dreamy finish.
Hearth Artisan Pizza
$$ | (907) 222-0888 | WEBSITE
Too many pizza places in Anchorage are like, ‘You can choose between plain cheese or maybe pepperoni.’ But Hearth Artisan Pizza does pizza the way we wish more places would. There is no limited selection. Instead, you get your pick of any pizza from the regular menu, including options like the Voodoo Child and the Farmers Pie. The only catch is that certain pizzas might be richer than others.
Our beet salad appetizer was on the smaller side, but at least the Caesar salad with blackened chicken was a generous portion. The affordable bill and awesome service make it a must-try, whether for dinner or simple desserts like pudding and mousse.
Luigi’s Pizza
$ | (907) 562-1920 | WEBSITE
The medium cheese and pepperoni pizza, which is normally $8, is reason enough to prioritize Luigi’s during a busy weeknight. Get a mega meat pizza to share, and suddenly their friendly atmosphere feels less like Anchorage and more like the set of a classic pizza joint. The halal and vegetarian options are an extra $2, but it’s worth it for one of Anchorage’s best.
Muldoon Pizza
$ | (907) 333-7711 | WEBSITE
Muldoon Pizza has been a staple for Anchorage families for years, and you should head there now. It instantly became our favorite pizzeria in the area when we first tried it last winter, and it’s already one of the very top ones in Alaska, too. Thankfully, you aren’t missing out on the best pizza (the house special) if you opt for the classic menu. The 18-inch pie is the standout choice here. But we get just as excited about the other options here, like the meat pizza and lasagna.
Bella Vista Pizzeria
$$ | (907) 688-2221 | WEBSITE
Hats off to Bella Vista Pizzeria for being loyal to locals and not overcharging us. Few restaurants of this caliber are offering $25 large pizzas with mountain views. And there’s nothing thoughtless about this one, either. These are filling portions with not-cheap ingredients, like the steak and clams, and seafood Mediterranean pasta—a great example of a restaurant that wants your dollar to go further.
Chuck E. Cheese
$$ | (907) 274-9999 | WEBSITE
$25 for two hours of unlimited tokens at one of Anchorage’s 20 best pizza restaurants is a steal. To start, grab a slice of their great pizza, which combines a crisp crust, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese for a classic (and reliably kid-friendly) flavor combination. The stocked salad bar is a great side, and everything can be finished off with a challenging round at the downstairs crane claw game.
Stick to their classic entertainment vibe—the newer large screens and games don’t quite live up to the nostalgic charm of the older ones that have been around for over 20 years.
Sicily’s Pizza Muldoon
$$ | (907) 333-8000 | WEBSITE
Sicily’s Pizza Muldoon is what we recommend for folks looking for solid pizza without any gimmicks. Their straightforward approach is a great Anchorage option for those who want good food delivered hot and fresh, and some of our favorites here—like the medium stuffed crust pepperoni with sausage, spinach, bell peppers, olives, and tomatoes—are all prepared with care. Sadly, ordering can sometimes be tricky when one person is handling everything, creating a bit of a wait.
Jamico’s Pizzeria Restaurant
$ | (907) 277-5815 | WEBSITE
We love the deluxe pizza at Jamico’s, but in the spirit of saving time, let’s skip the delivery fee. Instead, grab the combo appetizer that’s just as satisfying, with wings arriving hot and crispy straight from the kitchen. The Jamico’s team is fantastic with families, so there’s no wrong choice between the Hawaiian pizza and bacon cheeseburger that one reviewer still dreams about.
Pizza Olympia
$$ | (907) 561-5264 | WEBSITE
Getting an authentic Greek feast here for under $35 feels like the find of the winter. The pizzeria is known for its pizza, but we love the seafood fettuccine on their menu. If you want the full Pizza Olympia experience, you can get the gyro pizza as your main course for an extra $12. That’s normally $24 (with an extra side) for dinner, so stick to the other options and spend that extra money on a proper meal here eventually.
Bread and Brew
$ | (907) 562-2739 | WEBSITE
Bread and Brew’s menu is like the cozy comfort board of Anchorage eateries, but we’ll help you navigate it. They’re serving lunch and dinner, but you should focus on the sandwiches. There’s a $12 sandwich combo and a $15 combo (but just on weekends)—the $12 lunch is the better deal because it includes a full sandwich with tomato basil soup or a grilled cheese with dipping sauce.
Round Table Pizza
$ | (907) 522-1007 | WEBSITE
Round Table Pizza’s lunch combo has most of our favorite items, like the King Arthur’s Supreme Pizza with its flavorful sauce and generous toppings, the fresh salad bar with pickled artichokes, and the personal-sized pizza for a satisfying meal (although that gluten-free crust option does sound promising, too). Go with the family so everyone can order a different pizza and salad. This way, you get to try a bit of everything.
Lalo’s Pizza Take Out
$ | (907) 375-9723 | WEBSITE
We’re really loving the pizza options at this Anchorage spot. You can order a classic cheese pizza as your main. Plus, pepperoni with homemade-style marinara, Philly cheesesteak, or even delicious wings as your meal. Those pizzas alone would cost $18 at most places. And the great specials with minimal grease are what we’d jump on from their affordable menu.
Palermo Pizza & Phillys
$ | (907) 334-3354 | WEBSITE
The no-frills pizza joint in Anchorage is the kind of place you might usually hit for a quick bite, but we think $25 for a large pepperoni pizza, Philly cheesesteak, and crispy fries is enough cause for regular visits. There’s also a $15 lunch combo that includes wings and a drink, but we’d recommend prioritizing dinner here.