With legendary thin-crust joints, family-run parlors that have been slinging pies for decades, and a couple of spots even folks in Destin rave about, Crestview’s pizza scene is buzzing. It’s easy to get overwhelmed choosing between Neapolitan-style, New York slices, or a classic Friday night pie. That’s why we’ve done the slicing for you. These are the 10 best pizza restaurants in Crestview for 2025.
Hideaway Pizza
$ | (850) 682-3225 | WEBSITE
On nights you’d rather not wait for a table, grab a pizza from Hideaway Pizza in Crestview. They serve classic pies that come hot and fresh, even during busy hours. Stick with whatever sounds good to you, but we highly recommend the extra cheese pizza that’s thick and loaded with cheese, along with the sausage pizza with buffalo mozzarella. There’s a cozy dining room with painted scenery on the walls, but there’s no shame in taking yours to go and enjoying it while watching a movie at home.
Eagle’s Nest at Blackwater
$$ | (850) 331-3594 | WEBSITE
Eagle’s Nest at Blackwater is one of those Crestview spots—you know the type—and this family-friendly destination, with a focus on fresh pizza and flavorful Southern dishes, is clearly earning its place among the area’s best. Thanks to live music from bands like Lower Alabama and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, the lively restaurant is an easy choice for family dinner or a night out with friends.
Start with a perfectly mixed drink from the bar and the highly praised pork belly and cheese grits before moving onto the best buffet we’ve experienced in months (especially during special events like the Mother’s Day Brunch), amazing fresh and hot pizza, and fun specials that are always worth trying.
Hunt Brothers Pizza
$ | WEBSITE
When you first walk into the Marathon station, you’ll notice the pizza boxes stacked neatly behind the counter, each one printed with a Christian message. Everything at this Crestview spot is that straightforward, especially their $12 medium pizza that comes with unlimited toppings at no extra charge. It’s all satisfying—pizzas have generous toppings and a non-greasy crust that you won’t find at a lot of other places.
We’re talking about options like breakfast pizza or classic pepperoni with extra cheese. While most of the menu focuses on pizza, but you can (and should) add on the wings, which are small but packed with flavor.
Little Caesars Pizza
$ | (850) 683-8055 | WEBSITE
Little Caesars Pizza is bright, efficient, and has more hot-and-ready pizzas than a Friday night football game. There’s a simple counter setup that works perfectly for a quick grab-and-go meal (they’ll even have your order ready in minutes if you call ahead). From delicious pepperoni pizzas served piping hot to standout chicken wings, the menu here is exactly what you’d expect from a convenient pizza spot.
There’s also a friendly staff like Kevin, Camryn, and Kayla who keep things moving even when it gets busy.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (850) 682-5495 | WEBSITE
Domino’s Pizza is a 5-seat fast-food spot serving some of the most satisfying pizzas in Crestview. Located on a busy street, the menu is part-classic, part-customizable, and all reliable. It features from specialty pies, like the half pineapple/ham and half pepperoni/bacon with extra cheese, to the vegetarian options and requests for special dietary needs. There are still some space constraints, but it feels more like a friendly neighborhood joint.
While the setup is decidedly compact, every pizza is consistently and generously topped, making it the perfect balance for a quick dinner or casual night with family.
Brooklyn Bar & Grill
$ | (850) 331-3442 | WEBSITE
Crestview’s Brooklyn Bar & Grill serves up consistently satisfying comfort food, but it’s also just a cozy spot to settle in for a hearty meal. The family-friendly vibe feels like a neighborhood gathering spot since everyone walking in seems to know each other and the friendly staff. Although this place is technically known for its pizza, almost everything else coming off their grill works just as impressively. Go for the enormous, perfectly balanced chicken and waffles.
The kitchen makes a variety of standout dishes, and while they’re all delicious, the one featuring the Crestview pizza with bacon, chicken, and ranch is the one we’d recommend to anyone looking for a truly satisfying bite.
Brooklyn Pizza
$ | (850) 306-3355 | WEBSITE
You can get all kinds of New York-style pizza at this Crestview spot, from the best loaded pies in town to delicious lasagna and garlic knots. They also have some surprisingly affordable lunch deals. Top your meal with cannoli, brownies, or a warm welcome from the incredibly friendly staff. If you need extra inspo, check out their generous portions and huge servings.
Pizza Hut
$ | (850) 682-9960 | WEBSITE
With a stuffed crust pizza as iconic as the red roof itself, and a drive-thru that stays open until late, Pizza Hut is where we go for hot, fresh pies and convenient takeout. Drop by on a casual evening and start with things like their perfect sides, then move on to a 14″ Meat Lover’s pizza or one of their other positively reviewed options.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (850) 270-2300 | WEBSITE
Marco’s Pizza is a pizza joint that works for a solo dinner, groups of friends, or anyone whose love language is pepperoni pizza. Must-orders are the Greek salad—filled with banana peppers, olives, green onions, tomatoes, and topped with feta cheese in a phenomenal way—and the cheesy bread, which is cooked perfectly without burning.
Marco’s also makes a mean pepperoni pizza, so if you’re in the neighborhood and don’t have time to cook, wait for your hot delivery with a side of that savory sauce and generous toppings.
Hungry Howie’s Pizza & Subs
$ | (850) 689-0990 | WEBSITE
Drive right past and you might overlook it. Hungry Howie’s Pizza & Subs, the cozy and reliable pizza joint, sits in a Crestview strip mall next to a hardware store, a laundromat, and exactly zero other cozy and reliable pizza spots. But it’s worth stopping for some of the best salads, specialty pizzas, and cheesy bites in town. The bright dining area is anchored by a warm counter on one side, an open kitchen busy with cooks on the other, and classic rock playing overhead.
If you can’t grab a booth, try for one of the vinyl seats at the window table. The chef salad with crisp greens, Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza with its garlic ranch crust, and perfectly baked flatbread with crunchy seasoned crust taste just as excellent there.