Whether you’re debating the merits of a classic New Haven apizza with a new flame or sharing your 47th pepperoni slice with your forever person, pizza nights deserve that extra touch of magic. So, from cozy neighborhood joints perfect for a first date to bustling spots where you can finally settle the ‘pineapple debate’ with your partner, let this guide lead you to Hartford’s perfect pie.
Infinity Music Hall – Hartford
$$ | (860) 560-7757 | WEBSITE
Catching a show at Infinity Music Hall might be the closest you can get to a front-row concert experience in downtown Hartford. This music venue has a classy atmosphere, excellent sound quality, and plenty of seats with no bad views where you can enjoy live performances and grab drinks from the great bar. On most nights, Infinity Music Hall has a full room of people dancing and chatting over affordable tickets and $5 parking until the encore ends.
A-1 Pizza
$ | (860) 525-6666 | WEBSITE
A-1 Pizza is a great pizza spot that’s good to keep in mind if you have a last-minute game night in Hartford. It’s in a bright room with checkered tablecloths and a counter in the corner, and we’ve usually had luck walking in without a wait and getting a booth. Get the vegan pizza, the turkey grinder, and their must-try appetizer – sausage with dipping sauce. It’s a huge portion, but if you ask nicely, they might split it for you. In other words, you have no excuse not to try this.
Hartford Pizza Garden
$ | (860) 488-4507 | WEBSITE
Hartford Pizza Garden is a classic, vintage pizza spot tucked into Hartford’s dining scene. If this sounds familiar, you might also recall the city’s longstanding love affair with both Detroit and New Haven styles. Now, the space at Hartford Pizza Garden features high ceilings, comfortable booths and tables, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes each slice feel special.
The outstanding pizzas and passionate owner make this one of the more exciting local options in the area, but you and your friends can still choose to either keep it casual with a slice of Hartford hot Detroit style with pepperoni and hot honey or go all-in on a whole pie like the perfect goat cheese and fig with arugula and balsamic drizzle.
City Pizza
$$ | (860) 236-2616 | WEBSITE
If you drive by City Pizza during the day, you might think it’s just another Hartford pizza joint with a simple storefront and basic dining area. That’s because, like hidden gems and neighborhood favorites, this unassuming spot reveals its true character once you step inside. The perfect blend of cheeses on thin crust, generous toppings, and the friendly owner who remembers regulars are the real reasons why you should come here.
So the next time you want to enjoy the best pizza in town while simultaneously grabbing a delicious panini and experiencing top-notch service, try this place.
Chris’s Pizza & Deli
$ | (860) 296-0511 | WEBSITE
This pizza and deli spot is one of those rare Airport Road places that makes you forget you’re just minutes from Hartford’s hustle. But now they’re serving up huge portions, friendly service, and that to-die-for lemon cake every day starting in the morning. The owner is typically around greeting customers (with those amazing aromas wafting through the air), but we’d recommend arriving before the lunch rush since parking can be a challenge with only a few spots on the side of the building.
Fat Franks Pizza
$ | (860) 296-3111 | WEBSITE
From the Meat Lover’s piled high with toppings to the square-cut slices perfect for little hands, this pizza joint is one of your best takeout options in Hartford. And for the first time, they’re offering their tasty pies for dine-in, with a few booths available for walk-ins from 4-8pm any day except Sunday. So instead of trying to impress your friends with fancy recipes or complicated plans, just head to Fat Franks and ask them to savor the cheesy goodness of the Fat Frank’s Specialty.
The Brownstone
$ | (860) 969-6128 | WEBSITE
Think of The Brownstone as the perfect neighborhood spot to grab a great beer and share a pizza with friends. Although (unlike other neighborhood pubs), they serve a delicious Margherita pizza with thin crispy crust and the right amount of cheese. This Irish-inspired spot in Hartford is open for lunch and dinner every day, and we especially like pairing a local IPA with the tasty wings and the classic pizza with great tasting sauce.
It has a lively atmosphere that feels like the lovechild of a comfortable date spot and a fun night out with family.
Mr Pizza House
$ | (860) 242-9771 | WEBSITE
In 2025, Mr Pizza House remains a reliable late-night option in Hartford with decent reviews. The result: a convenient spot where you can grab a slice, enjoy the friendly staff, and appreciate the attentive young woman at the counter. It’s one of our go-to moves after hours, since you can simultaneously savor pizza with the right balance of sauce and cheese and appreciate the crust’s crispiness and softness.
However, service can be slow, with orders sometimes not being ready on time, and quality can be inconsistent, though lunch service tends to be more pleasant. Despite this, the pizza is good and edible, making it a solid choice when you need a quick bite.
HFC Chicken & Pizza
$$ | (860) 246-0111 | WEBSITE
If you’ve been craving something that hits all the right comfort food notes, head over to HFC Chicken & Pizza. This popular local spot in Hartford is perfect for a quick lunch break whether you want to grab something to go, or settle in for a satisfying meal that might become your new regular. HFC Chicken & Pizza has a clean, spacious interior with big windows where you can stop by for a slice or a whole pie any day of the week, but the real stars are the Tikka and Triple cheeseburgers.
While the wait times can be a bit longer during peak hours, the convenient parking right in front makes up for it. On the menu, you’ll also find vegetarian options like Vegie Pizza and salad, all made with fresh ingredients and flavorful sauces. The crust is incredible, and the chicken is always hot and juicy—just what you need when that pizza craving strikes.
Pitta Gourmet
$ | (860) 527-7380 | WEBSITE
If you’re simply looking to eat something that tastes good on our next night in Hartford, head to Pitta Gourmet. This excellent neighborhood spot is one of the best pizza restaurants in the area, and while most of their high-quality party-size pizzas cost around $25, they also offer delivery and takeout options every day.
Sorella
$$ | (860) 244-9084 | WEBSITE
This Italian restaurant in Hartford is one of our favorite date spots – their welcoming, interestingly-decorated space with a view of the Pratt St. pedmall is the perfect place to share garlic cheese bread and chicken parm with someone you hope likes you back. In addition to a good selection of wines at reasonable prices, Sorella also does excellent appetizers and entrees that’ll make you want to become a regular.
Even if the pasta is slightly overcooked, you can always relax with the consistently friendly and attentive service inside.
ABC Pizza House
$ | (860) 247-0234 | WEBSITE
ABC Pizza House is the beloved pizza joint that has been serving Hartford locals for years. The Hartford spot is known for its limited indoor seating but keeps customers returning with its consistently great taste and fast, friendly service. The pizza features a sweet yet savory red sauce and a cheesy, doughy base with a crispy crust that some might find a bit greasy. For those craving something different, the Philly cheese steak grinder is a must-try.
From the classic pies and hearty grinders to large sheet pizzas for parties, all of the offerings should give you and your family more to enjoy than just a quick meal. The restaurant also provides prompt delivery for larger orders, ensuring there’s plenty to go around—even the kids at the party loved it, and there were plenty of leftovers to savor later.
Al’s Pizza and Deli
$ | (860) 216-6568 | WEBSITE
After being a go-to spot for quick, reliable meals in Hartford for years, Al’s Pizza and Deli continues to deliver exactly what you want. And if there was only one place we could grab a fast, satisfying lunch in the area, we’d choose Al’s every time. Come here to find consistently delicious food like the meatball calzone, which is large and tastes freshly made with good pizza sauce, being served by staff who are attentive and welcoming with genuine smiles.
The casual counter-service setup upfront is usually busy with regulars picking up orders, but you can always find a simple table nearby for a more relaxed, no-fuss meal experience. The owner prepares fresh soup daily, and the fruit salad and sandwiches are always fresh and enjoyable, perfect for meetings or a casual bite.
Woodland Pizza Restaurant
$ | (860) 293-1059 | WEBSITE
The team behind this local favorite has been serving up consistently impressive cheese pizza for years. The essential thing to order here is the classic cheese pie, which you can think of as the gold standard for Hartford pizza. It’s a straightforward creation with a crispy crust, balanced sauce, and quality mozzarella that melts perfectly in every bite. Woodland Pizza also has a warm and friendly staff, so bring your family and share one of the city’s most beloved pizzas.
NY – NY Pizza Restaurant
$ | (860) 296-1177 | WEBSITE
NY – NY Pizza Restaurant is the family-friendly spot from the team behind the best New York-style pies in Hartford, and it’s also where you should have your next casual family dinner in the area. The combination of fresh pizza with a slightly thicker crust, perfectly crunchy wings, and quick delivery service makes this neighborhood spot feel more like a classic New York slice joint – just without the parking hassle.
None of the food costs more than $15, and you can almost always get your hot and fresh meal delivered right to your door without much of a wait.
Kent Pizza 3
$ | (860) 247-1966 | WEBSITE
Kent Pizza 3 is a reliable neighborhood pizza joint in Hartford where you can grab a feta cheese and onion pizza on a Tuesday night, but it’s also a solid choice for a casual group hangout. You can go the single slice and soda route, or easily have a more substantial meal involving a whole pie and some grinders. Order for delivery when you want timely service from friendly staff, or stop by for a quick pickup when you don’t want to deal with the hassle of cooking after a long day.
Sampizza Bar
$ | (860) 461-1669 | WEBSITE
For a lively pizza night with family or friends in Hartford that you’ll remember fondly for weeks, Sampizza Bar is your top choice. This Brazilian-influenced pizza spot (under new ownership) serves pies like the classic Margherita, tasty Brazilian pizzas, and delicious vegetarian options with fresh ingredients you won’t find at other local joints.
The food is equal parts flavorful and satisfying, meaning your group will likely be too busy enjoying every slice and sipping fantastic cocktails like the strawberry and passion fruit caipirinha to notice the time passing.
Angelina’s Pizzeria
$ | (860) 232-4080 | WEBSITE
Hartford has plenty of spots to grab a slice and even more places to find friendly service, but if you want to enjoy them both at the same time, you should head to Angelina’s Pizzeria. They serve delicious, affordable thin-crust pizzas made with fresh ingredients, and the welcoming dining area has plenty of tables and booths that make customers feel like family.
It’s an ideal spot for feeding a small group or a large party, and even though the cheese pizza is especially popular, the huge slices and variety of vegetarian options mean you’ll rarely leave disappointed.