One undeniable fact we can all rally behind: pizza is perfection. Whether it’s Neapolitan-style from a cozy corner spot, loaded Chicago deep-dish, or a wood-fired masterpiece with bubbling cheese—it seems every region has unlocked this delicious equation: Crust + Toppings = Joy. So in the name of culinary research (and because we craved a proper slice), we present this guide to Lakewood’s finest pizza.
Pizzeria Leopold
$ | (303) 248-7208 | WEBSITE
When you think of Pizzeria Leopold, the first thing you probably think of are those perfect, chewy crusts that require you to savor every bite. But if you take off your pizza goggles, you’ll notice that this charming, cozy spot in Lakewood has burrata on the menu. And while this creamy ball might not look like much, don’t let its simple appearance fool you. It has a rich, milky center wrapped in a delicate skin that melts in your mouth.
A plate of this is so satisfying, if you were eating this while taking a polygraph test, you could lie about anything and still pass.
Jet’s Pizza
$ | (720) 912-5387 | WEBSITE
Compact, often bustling, and with the aroma of fresh dough filling the air, this pizza spot on Wadsworth feels like a neighborhood gathering at your favorite local joint. We love the deep-dish style or the healthier options that are rich with quality ingredients. They come served on that famous fresh-made dough that’s crispy on the outside and chewy within, and are topped with premium toppings and plenty of flavor for satisfaction.
Ordering by phone is the best way to ensure that you actually get your hands on some deals, since the online system can be tricky. You don’t want to miss out when the pizza party is in full swing.
Pizzeria Lui
$ | (303) 922-3202 | WEBSITE
Tucked away in a bustling Lakewood neighborhood, it’s no wonder Pizzeria Lui has become a local institution. The sourdough crust arrives with perfect bubbles and a slight char, and the friendly service starts with genuine smiles and prompt attention. These details are wonderful, but it’s the exceptional pizza that makes the visit memorable—specifically the pepperoni with jalapenos and smoked mozzarella. And at $24 for a large, this definitely falls under the category of “Worth Every Penny” pizza.
The toppings are flavorful and high-quality, with just enough heat from the jalapenos, all resting beautifully on that crispy, chewy, well-balanced crust.
Cicis Pizza
$ | (720) 779-2424 | WEBSITE
Cicis Pizza’s all-you-can-eat buffet is solid, but it’s their cheese pizza that keeps us returning to this family-friendly Lakewood spot. The first must-grab is the classic cheese pizza that looks like the perfect version of the after-school snack your kids dream about. It has a soft and chewy crust, and is topped with gooey melted cheese. We also like the generous portions of pepperoni on our other favorite, the pepperoni pizza.
This has a slightly crispy crust with just a touch of chewiness, with the savory pepperoni slices adding some saltiness into the mix.
240 Union Restaurant
$$ | (303) 989-3562 | WEBSITE
240 Union Restaurant sounds like a fine-dining destination, but instead of stuffy formality and someone fussing over a wine list, this white-tablecloth spot in Lakewood serves the best pizza in Colorado. From classic margherita with fresh basil, to Colorado lamb t-bone pizza with rosemary, to mushroom linguini pizza with truffle oil, it’s impossible to make a bad choice.
There are options like PEI mussels appetizer pizza, tempura shishito peppers pizza with chili paste, and amaretto chocolate pot de creme dessert pizza, which all have a satisfying crispy or chewy texture depending on how the pizza is prepared. The dining room can be a bit noisy, but feel free to show up for a special occasion and curate your own pizza tasting.
Ignazio’s Kitchen Restaurant and Pizza
$ | (720) 912-2337 | WEBSITE
“Diavola jalapeño pizza” might sound like it would cause fiery mouthfuls and a reaction similar to what happens when biting into a ghost pepper. But the delicious diavola jalapeño pizza at Ignazio’s Kitchen in its cozy strip mall location is actually quite balanced. The crispy crust comes with plenty of melted cheese and spicy toppings and has just enough smoky heat from the jalapeños. While we’re here, we also like to order their Arancini appetizer.
These are golden with a creamy center, and come with a tangy marinara sauce that nicely contrasts with the rich pizza.
Big Daddy’s Pizza and Bar Lakewood
$ | (303) 736-6090 | WEBSITE
Like any member of the Big Daddy’s family, this Lakewood pizza spot is always popular. But while this local favorite’s reputation is responsible for some of the crowd, it’s also because of the delicious food, particularly their wings. Their perfectly crispy wings are loaded with juicy flavor and a satisfying crunch. And while these wings are great, even better is their 26-inch party pizza. This has a fresh, tasty crust paired with quality ingredients and can feed a whole group with ease.
Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta
$ | (303) 988-3121 | WEBSITE
Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta is a well-known spot, especially among those from the east coast. Unlike them, we’re not going to be quiet about their N.Y. style pizza. We’re shouting from the top of every rooftop we can find (well, the ones that actually have decent views) for everyone to try it. The crust, sauce, and cheese are of exceptional quality. The thinner crust gives each slice a pleasant crispiness, but without feeling so brittle it’s like eating a cracker.
And the cheese holds up beautifully—never sliding off even when loaded with toppings. The welcoming atmosphere and great service make it a popular choice, though we’ve heard occasional grumbles about staff attitude. At around $18-22 for a large pie, it’s a solid deal for authentic east coast-style pizza that remains a go-to destination despite some inconsistencies.
Pizzeria Forte
$ | (303) 974-1034 | WEBSITE
The Sicilian pizza at this cozy Lakewood spot might be more closely related to a thick-crusted pie—but Pizzeria Forte literally translates to ‘Strong Pizza’, and we’re not going to argue with strength. There are only a few standout items: the must-try Sicilian pizza with its true crunch outside and soft crust inside, and the mouthwatering meatball and sausage sandwiches featuring perfectly balanced soft and crusty bread, melted cheese, and the right amount of flavorful sauce.
They’re substantial, with one slice alone sufficing as a satisfying snack. So if you’ve come to Lakewood on an empty stomach, an order will prevent you from impulsively devouring everything in sight—though with attentive staff like Ben treating everyone like VIPs, you might just want to.
Abrusci’s Fire & Vine
$$ | (303) 232-2424 | WEBSITE
Abrusci’s Fire & Vine in Lakewood has an Italian-inspired menu with a handful of different pasta dishes, but our two favorites are the rigatoni and sausage and the halibut. The rigatoni and sausage is full of savory flavor, has a perfect al dente texture, and is covered in a rich tomato sauce. For a vegetarian option, the shrimp stack has a crisp freshness, and a bright, zesty filling that receives added depth from lemon and a pleasant creaminess from avocado.
Little Caesars Pizza
$ | (720) 974-2620 | WEBSITE
Little Caesars Pizza’s South Sheridan branch has the ideal quick-service setup perfect for grabbing a hot meal after a long day, but it also works for a casual family dinner with the kids. Regardless of why you’re here, make sure to try their pretzel with cheese sauce pizza. This pizza has a fresh-made crust that’s ready in just ten minutes, and it comes with a cheese sauce that can be ordered as a special request.
The pretzel pizza has that signature ‘A1’ quality with consistent flavor, while their crazy puffs option is kid-friendly with a fun, simple appeal. Even if you leave unsure about your next meal plan, at least you’ll leave with a newfound appreciation for their quick, hot, and ready service.
Nicolo’s Chicago Style Pizza
$ | (303) 969-9000 | WEBSITE
Nicolo’s Chicago Style Pizza is a neighborhood favorite that makes it one of our top picks in Lakewood. But whether we’re here for a family dinner, party order, or casual takeout, we always make sure the gluten-free options are on the table. Each deep-dish pizza is loaded with fresh ingredients like an overstuffed suitcase, but the crispy crust keeps everything perfectly contained.
It’s finished off with a generous layer of flavorful marinara sauce and has an exciting mix of savory meats and cheeses that makes each slice hearty yet balanced—a phenomenon we’re calling the ‘Nicolo’s Magic.’
BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse
$$ | (720) 927-4260 | WEBSITE
BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse serves up a variety of food and drinks in a friendly atmosphere, with dishes that range from average to outstanding. The Prime Rib Dip and Philly might be considered just okay, but the Brewhouse Chicken and guacamole bacon burger are juicy and fresh. For those looking for a satisfying meal, the fried Mahi Mahi tacos are a good-sized and tasty option. The service is generally friendly, with waitress Ajia being attentive and accommodating.
If you’re hosting an event, the manager and staff, especially Jamilla and David, are very helpful and make the experience smooth for large groups. The restaurant features comfy booths and a cozy outdoor patio, making it a welcoming spot to enjoy a meal or drinks. For those seeking a fun treat, the pizookie dessert is delicious. Despite some average dishes, the friendly service and enjoyable atmosphere encourage guests to return.
Johnny’s New York Pizza & Pasta
$ | (303) 935-8818 | WEBSITE
The menu at Johnny’s New York Pizza & Pasta is like something out of a New York City guidebook: With pizza styles that can either be thin or thick crust, how many different slices does Johnny’s offer? And using our basic arithmetic, we’ve calculated that this Lakewood spot has enough variety to satisfy any pizza craving, putting it in first place for most authentic New York-style options in Colorado. But more important than just having a bunch to choose from is that they’re all delicious.
Some of our favorites are the classic cheese, pepperoni, and sausage pizzas, all of which come with perfectly balanced sauce and cheese, and loaded with flavor. While these aren’t technically gourmet artisanal pies, they have the same satisfying heartiness—like a savory hug from the Big Apple.