Whether it’s for family dinners, casual nights out, or just satisfying that cheesy craving, Mount Juliet is quietly becoming one of Middle Tennessee’s pizza hotspots. From the cozy neighborhood joints near Providence Marketplace to the artisanal spots popping up along Lebanon Road, it’s all one delicious discovery zone—and no one can deny there are more quality pies here than most realize.
From classic New York slices to wood-fired Neapolitan beauties, here’s where to grab the best pizza in Mount Juliet.
Painturo’s
$ | (615) 754-4443 | WEBSITE
There is no shortage of great pizza in Mount Juliet, which is what made the discovery of this cafeteria-style Italian spot something of a pleasant surprise. But all it took was one lunch to put any preconceived notions to rest. Not only is Painturo’s calm, casual atmosphere a perfect addition to the town’s midday meal rotation, the food is fantastic.
The menu is varied—probably a little too varied—so we recommend concentrating mostly on the pizza, then adding in dishes like pinwheels, baked spaghetti, and meatball sliders. The diamond cut slices are perfectly crisp, and the sauce on the pinwheels is particularly praised for its flavor. The lasagna and portion sizes are also noted as being good. For a meal that comes in under $40 for two, with food that’s hot and fresh, it’s a great little lunch spot.
They offer both inside and outside seating, and on special occasions they can accommodate larger groups in private rooms.
Mia Pizza
$ | (615) 288-8148 | WEBSITE
Mount Juliet has plenty of pizza joints, and many of them are decent. But the standout is Mia Pizza. The beloved local spot serves up pies like a cheeseburger pizza with a thin crust, and a sauce with a distinct tomato and basil flavor that really makes the dish. Beyond what you’re going to eat though, Mia Pizza is just a welcoming, casual place to grab a bite, enjoy the reasonable prices, and appreciate a community spot that’s never lacking in friendly staff and good vibes.
Jersey Oven Bagels
$ | (615) 553-2437 | WEBSITE
Outside of a classic New York bagel shop, the bagels at Jersey Oven Bagels aren’t much different than any other decent spot in Mount Juliet. That said, you’re not here for a perfect replica of a NYC everything bagel—you’re here for an all-out breakfast scene.
Spend even fifteen minutes here waiting for your pork roll egg and cheese and you’ll see regulars grabbing their sausage, egg & cheese on fresh everything bagels, families indulging in sweet treats like French toast bagels with cinnamon sugar cream cheese, and weekend crowds forming lines out the door. Take a deep breath, sit back, and enjoy the show.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (615) 754-3200 | WEBSITE
Marco’s Pizza in Mount Juliet is one of the area’s great pizza spots, and it’s not just because they have delicious pies. It’s because any kind of pizza lover will have a fantastic meal at this family-friendly but welcoming restaurant. Maybe you’re the kind of person who sticks mostly to classic pepperoni and cheese, or maybe you live and breathe by the generous toppings and fresh ingredients. Either way, you’re in good hands.
Order the cheesy sticks, a fresh hot pizza with your favorite toppings, or our favorite value meal in town, and you’ll see what a great all-around pizza restaurant looks like.
Calabria Brickoven Pizzeria – Mt. Juliet
$ | (615) 288-8078 | WEBSITE
A pizza at Calabria is as authentic as it is incredibly affordable. At this brickoven pizzeria in a converted space in Mount Juliet, a large specialty pie costs around $25 at most, officially making it one of the best-value Italian spots in Middle Tennessee (if not the region). That said, it’s clear where your money is going. Staff with genuine smiles present Italian-style pies with effortless poise, and the quick, straightforward menu unfolds like a seamless culinary play.
Between the Margherita with its perfect saltiness, the Spicy Diavola with its fantastic cheese pull, and the most ludicrously good crust we’ve ever tasted, the pizza-heavy cooking still haunts our cravings—and our dinner plans.
Fayzano’s Pizza Mt. Juliet
$ | (615) 991-1181 | WEBSITE
Fayzano’s Pizza is a Mount Juliet staple. The family-run pizza joint has been serving the neighborhood for years and has had more hungry families walk through its doors than a Little League team after a game. Is this the greatest pizza you’ve ever had? No. But everything from the pepperoni and sausage pizza to the buffalo wings to the garlic knots they bring out fresh will be satisfying. It’s not a fancy place and they certainly keep things simple.
But with a huge roll in front of you and the owner checking on your table, who’s really complaining?
Jet’s Pizza
$ | (615) 754-4100 | WEBSITE
Mount Juliet will always be known for its family-friendly neighborhoods and growing suburban charm, but there’s also a pizza culture that keeps locals coming back for more. And at the center of it is Jet’s Pizza. This reliable spot takes delivery pizza to a satisfying level: consistently good pies with various crust options, wings that hit the spot for game day, and a calzone that arrives larger than you’d expect, almost like a personal feast built for a hungry afternoon.
The food is straightforward, so if it’s your first time, order through their app or text system—and don’t forget to check for those text-to-order discounts.
Jonathan’s Grille
$$ | (615) 288-2167 | WEBSITE
When Jonathan’s Grille opened in Mount Juliet, it quickly became one of our favorite spots in town to grab some comfort food. Now the welcoming eatery has settled into its reputation, offering a lively environment that keeps locals coming back. The atmosphere’s pretty consistent—a spacious, sit-down dining room perfect for catching a game or meeting friends—and the menu here is reliably satisfying.
You’ll find favorites like the crispy, flavorful chicken tenders and a variety of comfort dishes with a gourmet touch alongside popular two-for-one specials that make happy hour a highlight. Check out the TVs, too. The Christian lights and numerous screens are the best you’ll find for watching sports in the area.
Ziggy’s Pizza & Sandwich Shop
$ | (615) 449-8887 | WEBSITE
Being a pizza and sandwich shop in a town with plenty of options can be a tough gig, but Ziggy’s has found a way to do it. Located in the heart of Mount Juliet, you may have driven past Ziggy’s on your way to a chain restaurant and not even realized it. But this spot is serving generous portions at half the cost of those bigger places. If you aren’t looking to go all-in on a whole pizza, they have an excellent Italian sub and a SLAMM sandwich you need immediately.
Little Caesars Pizza
$ | (615) 773-7999 | WEBSITE
The drive-thru line at Little Caesars gives off the same energy as a Black Friday sale—the one at Walmart, not a boutique. Hot-and-Ready pizzas are in every car, big boxes of deep dish with extra toppings are handed through windows, and hungry families stuff garlic-buttered Cheesy Bread into their grocery bags. It’s a busy scene even by Mount Juliet standards, and while the pizza at Little Caesars is mostly decent, there’s still enough good stuff on the menu to ensure everyone leaves satisfied.
Stick to the deep dish and some crowd-friendly wings, and then spend the rest of your evening munching on affordable slices in your car (the app works well when the line’s long).
Ziggy’s Pizza and Subs
$ | (615) 754-2211 | WEBSITE
If you’ve been craving a proper pizza, head to Ziggy’s. The cozy Mount Juliet spot looks like a classic neighborhood joint tucked away in the suburbs. Like its reputation suggests, the place is heavy on flavor and light on pretense: checkered tablecloths, piping hot pies, craft sodas, and a classic rock playlist. Start with the veggie Xtreme that reminds us of a loaded garden, a few slices of pepperoni and bacon, and the random (but highly delicious) buffalo chicken. Meatball sub for a side?
Why not. Tennessee is no stranger to local pizza places, and Ziggy’s is more satisfying than most of them.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (615) 754-5175 | WEBSITE
After years of being a reliable neighborhood staple, this Domino’s on Lebanon Road continues to impress with its consistent quality and service. The space features a clean, modern interior with bright lighting and a convenient drive-in window for quick pickups. Our favorite pizzas here include the classic Pepperoni and the surprisingly good gluten-free options, but don’t skip the cheesy Breadsticks, which arrive perfectly warm and garlicky.
If you’re in a hurry, ordering is efficient—you could easily have your pizza ready in 15 minutes. Otherwise, we recommend planning ahead, grabbing a couple of two-liter sodas, and enjoying a straightforward, satisfying meal that won’t break the bank.