In an ideal world, every pizza joint would be a destination. That way, any craving could be satisfied with a perfect slice, and a mediocre night could be saved by a blistered crust and bubbling cheese. North Bay comes deliciously close to that dream, but you still need a guide to find the spots worth the trip. That’s why we’ve hunted down the ten best pies in town. Grab a napkin and get ready.
Greco’s Pizza
$ | (705) 474-6322 | WEBSITE
On the corner of Main Street in North Bay is Greco’s Pizza, a popular hometown favorite that’s basically a neighborhood pizza haven with loaded deluxe pies and fast delivery service. There’s a comfortable environment inside in case you want to dine in, and the friendly staff makes ordering here a great experience (we’d recommend trying the gourmet pizza for weekend meals).
If you get hungry while you’re in the area, Greco’s Pizza is also known for their bacon-wrapped scallops with cheese appetizer, where you can get dishes like thin crust pesto pizzas, meatlover pizzas, and some of our favorite spinach salads in town.
Milano Pizza & Wings
$ | (705) 840-2222 | WEBSITE
If you’ve ever stood in line at Greco’s waiting for a pizza that costs more than it should, while wondering ‘I wonder what this would be like if it were actually good and didn’t break the bank,’ we’ve got just the place for you. You won’t pay Greco’s prices, but if you do want to get the best deal there’s a pickup special you can order that’s available every day.
Or show up on weekends when the dining room’s packed—just go enjoy the crispy crust and loaded toppings because you’re getting real value.
Arugula
$$ | (705) 223-3400 | WEBSITE
With its bustling dining room, cozy patio overlooking Chippewa Creek, and more Mediterranean-inspired dishes than you can sample in one visit, it’s easy to spend an entire evening at Arugula in North Bay without even realizing it. On the menu, expect to find wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas like the popular Italian sausage pie, but the main attraction is the selection of nine different vegan pizzas featuring options like vegan “chicken” and vegan pepperoni.
They’re only available all day, but they’re a delicious way to enjoy a meal with friends in an atmosphere that feels significantly warmer than your last pizza chain experience. In the evenings, there’s also phenomenal service from cheerful staff and a comfortable vibe that makes you never feel rushed.
Bay Bistro
$ | (705) 493-0275 | WEBSITE
Love finding a cozy spot to eat, but tired of navigating complicated menus when you just want something delicious? Enter: Bay Bistro. It’s affordable to dine here, and all the dishes are flavorful. Head to Bay Bistro on a random weeknight to savor their phenomenal tofu sandwich, or show up with the family and settle in for a memorable meal.
Either way, you’ll have access to a diverse range of expertly crafted options—all bursting with flavor—plus vegetarian choices, accommodating service, and a modern, welcoming atmosphere.
Topper’s Pizza – North Bay
$$ | (866) 454-6644 | WEBSITE
We never thought we’d be craving cauliflower pizza from a tiny takeout spot in North Bay, but we also never expected to find such consistently satisfying pies without ever sitting down. There’s solid pizza from friendly staff who provide excellent service with a smile (but with more casual things like the popular small 8 topper and topper sticks) that you can grab for quick pickup, plus tasty garlic dip that pairs perfectly with standout items like the cheeseburger pizza.
It’s a great way to spend a Friday evening at home, while also convincing yourself you’re dining out by enjoying amazing pizza with just the right toppings and plenty of them.
Pizza Pizza
$ | (705) 497-1111 | WEBSITE
Everybody has their own preferences when ordering pizza. Some that sound traditional, and others a little more modern. At Pizza Pizza in North Bay, there’s no need to worry about “dietary restrictions” and “delivery times”—this is a fully family-friendly pizza situation, which means all you have to do is place that order and let some reliable staff handle the rest. Is this a solution to a problem that never really existed? Maybe.
But on the plus side, there’s a menu that provides vegetarian options for all those really picky eaters in your group that’ll make you feel like a thoughtful host.
Dr Pizza
$ | (705) 476-6911 | WEBSITE
Right in the heart of North Bay, Dr. Pizza is a straightforward spot offering quality pizza at great prices. The meat lovers pizza is particularly recommended, with high-quality toppings that have maintained their delicious taste for over 15 years. Grab a slice for around $4 or a whole pie starting at $18, making it more affordable than other places in town. The service is excellent, with quick and responsive staff who happily take ahead orders.
While the simple interior focuses on efficiency over ambiance, the overall experience of tasty pizza and good service makes Dr. Pizza a solid choice for anyone craving a delicious meal.
The Portage
$$ | (705) 474-8800 | WEBSITE
This lakeside restaurant by Trout Lake is an ideal place to gather with your family on a relaxed evening. Pizza is the focus here, but if your last attempt at a family outing ended in dietary restrictions and grumpy kids, there’s plenty of allergy-safe dishes, friendly service, and comfortable seating to enjoy while you watch other people enjoy their meals—especially since the atmosphere is usually fairly welcoming and easy to chat in.
East Side Mario’s
$$ | (705) 497-9555 | WEBSITE
In the pantheon of places you’ll only find in North Bay, East Side Mario’s sits right at the top, and the best spot to experience it is at their cozy location. It’s bustling every evening in the dining room and the atmosphere itself is exactly what you’d hope for, but warmer and more welcoming.
Order a plate of Calamari Al Diavolo for around $15 and a generous portion of Chicken Parmesan from the friendly staff inside, then settle into a comfortable booth and savor those fresh flavors when they arrive at your table—the highlight of each visit is the satisfying meal.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (705) 495-6969 | WEBSITE
There’s a pizza at Domino’s, but it plays a supporting role to the main attraction: service. This is a pizza spot that’s been around for years, and it doesn’t look like it’s changed much at all in that time. Despite the quick preparation of orders, there’s often a wait here on Friday and Saturday nights. Don’t worry, the food is affordable and you can just hang out with the friendly staff like Sonny and Sachinn.