Everyone’s asking where to find the best pizza in Pembroke Pines. Sure, you could drive across town for that Neapolitan pie your neighbor raves about. But if you’re a local who wants to make the most of a meal right here, we’ve got you covered. These are the spots worth your time—and your appetite.
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Pembroke Pines
$$ | (954) 248-2344 | WEBSITE
The number of family-friendly pizza spots in Pembroke Pines where you can have a low-key meal and not worry about parking is basically zero. Except for Mister O1.
This award-winning pizza spot is an ideal place to grab a slice, enjoy the cozy atmosphere, and sit in the spacious dining room – we recommend the Marco Pizza, a flavorful and perfectly made pie that is all we want to eat this week, and the attentive service from staff like Daniela and Veronica, who work together to ensure a clean and welcoming experience. Get ready to bring the kids on weekends to beat the dinner rush.
La Strega Cucina Italiana
$$ | (954) 441-3475 | WEBSITE
Pembroke Pines has its share of Italian spots, and it’s time to crown La Strega Cucina Italiana as one of the best. This cozy, sit-down restaurant tucked away in the area is the kind of place you try for a casual dinner, then find yourself booking again for the following weekend. That’s just what happens when a kitchen is turning out Italian classics this consistently delicious and satisfying.
The lasagna, chicken picatta, and seafood cioppini are all excellent, but it’s the perfectly cooked Branzino that will have you planning your next visit. And the one after that, and the one after that.
Little Caesars Pizza
$ | (954) 435-5003 | WEBSITE
When one of the best pizza restaurants in Pembroke Pines announced they were keeping their location open with updated service, we weren’t just hungry, we were ready to seize the pie (a school of thought known as crust-ace the moment). And Little Caesars doesn’t disappoint – operated by the team behind this popular chain, they’re serving reliable, satisfying pizza made with consistent ingredients.
They’re open all day, but we recommend ordering online for pickup and getting the classic pepperoni pizza, which includes perfectly melted cheese, crispy pepperoni slices, and a crust that’s chewy in all the right ways.
Chuck E. Cheese
$$ | (954) 437-8178 | WEBSITE
Despite what you might think about chain restaurants, being family-friendly can actually be a very good thing. Case in point: Chuck E. Cheese, the lively and fantastic spot in Pembroke Pines that will make you very glad to have kids in tow. Walking in is like stepping into a colorful wonderland – one that happens to have arcade games galore, vegetarian options like cheese or veggie pizza, and accommodating dietary restrictions with gluten-free pizza.
That includes the generally good food with pizza being a favorite, clean bathrooms, and helpful staff like Mauricio who assist with party setups. We told you it was family-friendly.
Pieology Pizzeria Pembroke Pines
$ | (954) 367-6656 | WEBSITE
Pieology Pizzeria Pembroke Pines isn’t the first pizza joint tucked away in a Pembroke Pines shopping center – they’re not even the first one to occupy the space they’re in – but tucked away or not, this is one of our favorite places to get a pie in this part of town. If you’re feeling adventurous, get the blue cheese and cilantro combination – old school dough with new toppings that creates a surprisingly harmonious flavor – or build your own with their excellent vegetarian options.
Get a side of their well-kept atmosphere and friendly service to balance it all out.
University and Sheridan street Capriccio plaza
$$$ | (954) 600-8499 | WEBSITE
If you’re like us, and love the cozy Italian atmosphere at University and Sheridan street Capriccio plaza, but don’t always feel up to making the trip to Pembroke Pines for it, we have good news: They’ve maintained everything that made us fall for this place originally. And not only did they keep the things that we adored about their classic little gem – namely, the live piano music that fills the main dining room and bar area – but they’ve also perfected the menu we already loved.
Our favorite standout is the salad with parmesan, artichokes, and sundried tomatoes, a fresh and delicious dish that’s the kind of generous, flavorful plate you thought only existed in your daydreams of a small spot in Italy.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (754) 231-2600 | WEBSITE
Marco’s Pizza is an ideal neighborhood pizzeria that also happens to serve pies you’ll want to eat every night of the week. This Pembroke Pines spot has a fantastic, low-key atmosphere with lots of cozy corners, making it ideal for a quick family meal, and a menu with highly satisfying pizzas. Get the classic cheese pizza – soft and fresh from the crust up – or the chicken wings – falling right off the bone, cooked exactly right, and served with a side of ranch we wish we could order on its own.
Pair it with whatever the friendly staff suggests: Their service is fast, and they have lots of convenient online ordering options, but they’ve always got great suggestions for whatever you’re craving.
Piacere Wood Fired Pizza Pines
$ | (954) 404-9070 | WEBSITE
A charming little pizza spot in a convenient Pembroke Pines location, Piacere Wood Fired Pizza Pines serves wood-fired pizzas with that perfect crispy-yet-chewy crust you dream about. That shouldn’t stop you from trying their other offerings, though – one standout is the personal pan Hawaiian pizza, a fantastic vegetarian option that hits all the right sweet and savory notes. The margherita pizza with its fresh basil and creamy mozzarella is another one of our favorites.
Pair it with their garlic bread – warm, buttery, and generously portioned – and you’re in for a wonderful meal. The friendly staff keeps things moving quickly, whether you’re dining in their super cute space or getting delivery, making it easy to order from them again and again.
Coley’s Pizza
$ | (954) 433-4477 | WEBSITE
Pembroke Pines’ Coley’s Pizza serves some of the best slices in town. We’re convinced they bake something much more addictive than cheese into their pepperoni pies (maybe it’s the super thin NY-style crust underneath), and we’d order their Wednesday special large pizzas by the dozen if we could.
But your experience at Coley’s isn’t just about the food: Walking into this place feels like you’re joining a Ninja Turtle party that everyone’s invited to – just you, the arcade games, and the friendly staff behind the counter. It’s the kind of place that every neighborhood in Florida needs, but only one has, so if you live in Pembroke Pines, make sure you take advantage of it.
Pizza Hut
$ | (954) 435-4400 | WEBSITE
In a particularly convenient twist of fate, the people behind Pizza Hut have opened a new location in Pembroke Pines. Located in a modern spot with a clean and pleasant atmosphere, Pizza Hut is faster, casual-er (just because we’re food writers doesn’t mean we can’t make up words), and serves pizza on a variety of tasty vehicles like breadsticks and classic pies. However, our go-to move is to keep it simple and order a ham pizza, along with a few sides like the breadsticks.
The staff is friendly and courteous, with one employee being particularly pleasant and helpful, and the delivery driver, Yolanda, provides exceptional service. While the crust may not be exceptional and the sauce can be too sweet, it’s a reliable option for take-out or delivery.