One of the questions we get most is, “Where should I get pizza in Richmond Hill?” Let us guess, you’re looking for something “authentic” but not pretentious, where you can grab a slice or feed the whole family. Believe it or not, such pizza spots do exist here.
Oak Ridges Pizza House
$ | (905) 773-9442 | WEBSITE
Nothing is quite as perfect for a big family dinner as a pizza feast from Oak Ridges Pizza House. And this accommodating spot is great for large orders, offers convenient pickup, and has exceptionally friendly staff. So if you’re one of the many families who need reliable, delicious food multiple times a week, you have a go-to option that won’t disappoint.
They have tasty options like the Deluxe and Meat Lovers pizzas, but we recommend focusing on the pepperoni pizza—especially with its incredible flavor and fresh toppings.
Pizzaiolo
$ | (905) 709-6000 | WEBSITE
The warm glow of the oven will welcome you at Pizzaiolo in Richmond Hill. The cozy atmosphere of this always-busy pizza joint is what makes it great for any casual night out. Plus, Pizzaiolo has generous slices and pitchers of craft beer. Their crispy crust or spicy Calabrese are perfect comfort foods, but we also like splitting a huge pie of Truffle Mushroom. After dinner, you’ll already be planning your next visit.
Pizzaville
$ | (416) 736-3636 | WEBSITE
This casual pizza joint in Oak Ridges feels like it’s one delivery box away from being a takeout spot. But Pizzaville is a sit-down restaurant with incredible pies, and the atmosphere feels like a constant celebration. It’s great for families so what you’re going to want to order here is the vegetarian special, which comes with fresh toppings and that famous sauce. Then just get to work slicing and sharing, and don’t be afraid to get your hands messy.
Mamma’s Pizza Richmond Hill
$ | (905) 889-0030 | WEBSITE
Like a secret handshake, asking for “garlic dipping sauce” with your order at this pizza spot in Richmond Hill will unlock one of the best casual meals in town. Mamma’s Pizza is a family-friendly restaurant that specializes in fast, delicious pies, which come fresh from their fancy pizza oven. It’s served hot and cheesy, perfect with that garlic sauce, and enjoyed in their nicely laid-out dining area.
This convenient location with ample parking is often busy, but it’s usually easy to get a table, especially in the morning when the staff is particularly cheerful.
Pizza Nova
$ | (416) 439-0000 | WEBSITE
Pizza Nova is a reliably solid pizza joint in Richmond Hill. And it’s the kind of place where the owner will not only make sure your order is correct, but will check in to see if you need anything else, too. The menu here is mainly pizza-focused, with plenty of toppings, but there are also bonuses like free chips for the kids (which is a nice touch).
Pizza Nova pops up frequently on people’s ‘I need to order pizza’ lists, so when you suggest it to your family, it’s basically like solving dinner for everyone.
Rose newyork richmond hill
$$ | (905) 773-0111 | WEBSITE
Rose New York Richmond Hill brings a Persian twist to the dining scene, offering a unique experience with its lively atmosphere and flavorful menu. Focus on the main dishes, from the signature Shirazi cutlet that truly stands out as the best in the city to shareable options like the tasty salami fries that everyone will let you enjoy since it’s your night after all.
Definitely save room for the cheeseburger—it’s moist and flavorful, and the overall dining experience remains highly recommended for its delicious food and cozy ambiance.
Reginos pizza richmond hill
$ | (905) 508-9000 | WEBSITE
The reliable charm of this pizza staple in Richmond Hill will make you happy to grab a quick bite or settle in for a full meal. The counter service is efficient and friendly, perfect for solo diners or families picking up for movie night. The straightforward menu is full of crowd-pleasing options, like the classic pepperoni, and the Hawaiian with its sweet pineapple chunks. And the best thing to order is the party-size pizza, which is ideal for gatherings of four or more.
It comes with your choice of toppings on a fresh, chewy crust, which is made daily and baked until perfectly crisp.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (905) 770-4344 | WEBSITE
Domino’s Pizza is a reliable and satisfying quick bite, right down to their perfectly thin crusts and gooey lava cakes. Its clean, welcoming space mixes fast-food efficiency with neighborhood charm—perfect for a weeknight dinner with family, cold drinks, and an equally cold delivery box. And as part of the popular chain, it proves that consistent quality runs in the family.
If Domino’s menu had a poster child, it’d be the Alfredo sauce pizza: delicious, creamy slices channeling the flavors of a comforting pasta dish. But there are many solid options, like the classic pepperoni with that crispy thin crust, or a fresh pie swimming in rich tomato sauce. Just make sure to get their lava cakes—they’re more of a dessert, but we’d gladly eat them as a meal replacement.
Pizza Pizza
$ | (416) 967-1111 | WEBSITE
Thanks to the crispy-on-the-outside, soft-on-the-inside crust, fantastic vegetarian options, and consistently ready-in-20-minutes service, this place feels like a top-notch pizza experience. It also doesn’t hurt that they have fantastic pizzas (with options like veggie pizza, halal pepperoni, and XL pizza) and mouthwatering wings. And let’s face it, quality pizza at a fantastic price is a treat that you owe yourself.
Toppings
$ | (905) 918-8677 | WEBSITE
It’s your casual night out, so according to the very unofficial Pizza Protocol, you’re allowed to make very specific, just-right demands. And if that means craving a spot that’s welcoming-but-not-too-formal, Toppings in Richmond Hill is a perfect pick. It’s situated in a clean, spacious setting with a bright, comfortable dining area that feels friendly yet not chaotic, and their tasty pizza options are excellent.
Some of our favorites are the Canadian pizza, BBQ chicken pizza, and a spicy twist on the jerk chicken sandwich. But the must-order item is their popular wings—they’re probably substantial enough to share with the whole table, too.
Pizza Shab
$$ | (905) 237-6443 | WEBSITE
Persian pizza is the best way to experience the regionally specific flavors at this Richmond Hill spot. And while late-night cravings are common, we’d rather satisfy them with Pizza Shab’s Bandari pizza. The deep-dish creation piled with sliced Persian sausage, tomato sauce, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella should be a centerpiece at every table.
The white base sauce and crispy, light crust are also delicious, and their vegetarian options are a great choice for anyone who thinks no meal is complete without amazing flavors.
Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Richmond Hill
$$ | (905) 709-4280 | WEBSITE
Remember when you were little, and kids with summer birthdays got to have pool parties? This place doesn’t have a pool, but you can channel the same energy with a lively Italian-style get-together. Plan to start off at the cozy bar in the center of the restaurant (since you can’t make a reservation). Once you secure a table, get ready for the bustling cafeteria-style atmosphere, which moves quickly.
Then, you’ll have all the time in the world to eat pasta and be glad you’re not relying on your loud friends to oversee the conversation.
Pizza Hut
$ | (905) 237-1114 | WEBSITE
In a world of generic pizza chains, this Pizza Hut is both reliable and surprisingly delightful. This Richmond Hill location mixes family-friendly nostalgia (hand-tossed classics) with ‘this is better than it needs to be’ touches (consistently crispy new crust, photo-worthy Cinnabon combos). The pizzas are straightforward but really satisfying. The hand-tossed veggie balances freshness with generous toppings, and the BBQ chicken with its sweet sauce is perfectly craveable.
Come here to make Tuesday night feel like a bigger deal than it actually is.
Oregano Pizza & Pasta
$$ | (905) 884-8610 | WEBSITE
For a place that’s been around for decades but still feels fresh and welcoming, check out Oregano Pizza & Pasta. This Italian spot in Richmond Hill is cozy, serves generous portions, and you can usually walk in without a wait. They have pizzas like the must-order grilled calamari and zucchini pizza, seafood pasta featuring shrimp, scallops, and salmon, and the best veal scallopine we’ve tried in the area.
They also have reasonable prices, with most dishes hovering around $20, making it perfect for a satisfying and affordable lunch.
Abruzzo Pizza
$$ | (905) 881-8222 | WEBSITE
Abruzzo Pizza is a Richmond Hill Italian spot, and take-out service is (very) easy to get. But because you’re the kind of person who appreciates a cozy, comfortable dining experience, you will happily plan your pizza night well in advance. And the fact that Abruzzo Pizza is highly recommended means that your family will be so excited to join your food-getting mission, they (probably) won’t complain about the drive.
Plus, the food is really good—with dishes like the Abruzzo’s Special Pizza loaded with toppings, delicious deep-fried panzarotti with meat sauce for dipping, and some incredible homemade gnocchi described as ‘little pillows of heaven.’