Trying to track down the perfect slice in Salina could leave you dizzy. Let this list be your guide instead. These are the pizza joints that show the most promise—though we can’t vouch for every pie we haven’t tasted ourselves. Go forth and be a pioneer, or just follow along as we reveal which spots we’ve checked out and loved.
Schlotzsky’s
$ | (785) 823-6526 | WEBSITE
Schlotzsky’s isn’t just another sandwich chain anymore. They’ve now opened a location in Salina, Kansas, right among the best pizza spots in town. The team behind this restaurant takes customer needs seriously, having developed protocols for gluten intolerance almost from the start, so it’s a thoughtful approach that shows. They’re serving gluten-free options for sandwiches and pizzas at the moment, but expect the same care across their entire menu.
The assistant general manager and staff provide exceptional service, ensuring everything runs smoothly even during busy times. Many customers enjoy the fresh sandwiches and soups, with the half sandwich ham and cheese being a particular standout. The restaurant offers good wheelchair accessibility and goes above and beyond with little extras like cookies if you have to wait.
Overall, Schlotzsky’s delivers an excellent dining experience with remarkable customer service that makes you want to return.
Big Cheese Pizza
$ | (785) 825-2283 | WEBSITE
Salina seems determined to have a pizza joint for every craving, and the latest is Big Cheese Pizza, a family-style restaurant with a cozy atmosphere. It’s their flagship location in Kansas, and it feels more like a bustling neighborhood spot than a typical chain. Tables are arranged with tight spacing, and the lights are bright white, creating a welcoming environment for all guests.
They offer a delicious 10-point pizza with a thin crust, and there are fresh mushroom options to choose from that come with homemade sauce. The menu also features fantastic sandwiches, and the potato salad served with them is believed to be homemade. Whether enjoying pizza or a Philly cheese steak sandwich, customers appreciate the good ingredients and variety of toppings.
The staff are easy to talk to, cheerful, and consistently friendly, providing good recommendations and ensuring orders are accurate. They also have kid-friendly features like quarter snatcher games, and military discounts are available. For a satisfying meal that won’t break the bank—expect to pay around $15-20 per person—this spot delivers with its friendly service and solid, homemade flavors.
Coop’s Pizzeria
$ | (785) 823-5556 | WEBSITE
Coop’s Pizzeria in Salina now offers fantastic food at reasonable prices, which means you can now grab a quick lunch special and then head over for a classic supreme pizza after. It’s known for its delicious wings and pizza, both well-priced. Expect menu items like the meatball grinder and pepperoni roll-ups, garlic cheese sticks and crusts with tasty sauce and toppings, all served in a dining area that’s clean and well-maintained with a relaxed and mellow atmosphere.
The service is fast and friendly, and the staff, including the chef, are helpful and accommodating, even preparing special orders like macaroni and cheese pizza for young children. The smell of the food often welcomes guests as they arrive, creating an inviting vibe. Overall, Coop’s provides a satisfying dining experience with tasty food and friendly service, whether you’re passing through or nearby.
Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza
$ | (785) 827-7900 | WEBSITE
Papa Murphy’s Salina location (yes, the one with the take-and-bake concept) is now offering their full menu daily. The restaurant’s signature fresh ingredients are still here, but they’re now doing double duty alongside a customization system that includes classic pizzas, specialty pies, and seasonal options like veggie-loaded creations. The friendly staff ensures quick service whether you order ahead or walk in, and the pizzas are always ready upon arrival.
Many customers appreciate the excellent quality, noting that the pies are fresh, generously topped, and never greasy. Although some have mentioned occasional website delays, the professional team makes pizzas on the spot while you wait. Overall, Papa Murphy’s remains a delightful choice for pizza lovers seeking great value and a pleasant experience.
Sbarro
$ | (785) 376-6033 | WEBSITE
If there weren’t enough family-friendly pizza spots in Salina already, Sbarro is the latest to join the fray. This traditional Italian concept has taken over a familiar space, making good use of the casual dining area that gets crowded during peak hours. Sbarro’s menu isn’t big on consistency, but it does include some satisfying Italian classics like Supreme pizza, delicious Stromboli, and other pizza varieties that families seem to enjoy.
The staff’s attitude varies between laid back and genuinely helpful, while the cleanliness during busy seasons has been questioned by some regulars. Still, most customers are open to trying different menu items despite the occasional ingredient shortages.
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
$ | (785) 404-1499 | WEBSITE
We haven’t pulled out our calipers for precise calculations, but Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom might just claim the title for the most loaded tater tots in Salina. This downtown staple specializes in hearty Chicago-style pies and satisfying calzones, including one pizza that comes with a perfect crust and fresh, flavorful toppings. Just know the Salina location is mostly a dine-in destination with a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Blue Skye Brewery and Eats
$$ | (785) 404-2159 | WEBSITE
Blue Skye Brewery and Eats, the must-visit Salina spot that’s been serving up incredible burgers since it opened, has become the go-to destination for anyone craving a great meal in a chill atmosphere. The space still feels like the living room of your friend who’s really into craft beer and sports, and the food has mostly stayed the same, too, with the Skye Burger on a gluten-free bun and sweet potato fries that are absolutely worth the $14 price tag.
The peanut butter and jalapeño burger remains a unique standout, and the in-house beers still complement everything perfectly. It’s the kind of place where you can hang out for hours, watch the game, and leave completely satisfied with both the generous portions and the friendly, efficient service.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (785) 825-7788 | WEBSITE
Behold, another reliable pizza chain in Salina—this one delivers hot pies right on time. Domino’s looks assembled from a fast-food starter pack with a chalkboard for kids, ample parking, and wheelchair-accessible everything. The pizzas come out consistently tasty, though, with toppings that stay hot, crusts that hold up, and service that stays polite.
Pizza Hut
$ | (785) 825-4422 | WEBSITE
Pizza Hut has entered its beef pizza era (along with the rest of Salina) with a standout offering that keeps customers coming back. The space feels like a classic pizza joint with bright lighting and comfortable booths, and they have all kinds of perfectly crunchy crust options, plus specialties like the recommended beef pizza. The service is from a standout manager and includes things like credits for wait times, fast delivery, and meals cooked to perfection.
Papa Johns Pizza
$ | (785) 827-7575 | WEBSITE
Salina’s been on a roll with pizza joints, and here’s a reliable one. This spot serves up the classic pizza favorites with mini bites that are soft, gooey, and flavorful, plus a crispy, flaky baked crust that hits just right. Expect quick service, thoughtful touches like included plates, and delivery drivers like Cory who ensure orders arrive fresh and prompt.
The atmosphere feels straightforward and welcoming, perfect for a quick bite or a special treat, with a vibe that keeps customers satisfied and eager to return.
Gambino’s Pizza
$ | (785) 577-8440 | WEBSITE
Salina’s favorite family-friendly pizza spot has settled into its local niche, and the experience feels familiar as ever: generous portions, quick delivery, and consistently hot food. Both the lunch buffet and the regular menu have grown in reputation, with standout items like the mobster pizza, dessert pizza, and spicy Capone and Taco pizzas. The crust texture is perfect, the toppings are generous, and many regulars say it reminds them of Godfather’s pizza—some even call it their new favorite.
Overall, Gambino’s feels like a valuable addition to the community, offering a satisfying dining experience with great pizza and friendly service.