There are all sorts of reasons why you might be craving pizza in Sebring. Here are a few: you’re celebrating a special occasion, you’ve had a long week, or your last homemade attempt ended with a smoke alarm serenade. Whatever the reason, here’s a list of places across town that’ll help you check ‘pizza’ off your craving list.
Pizza Hut
$ | (863) 385-1075 | WEBSITE
Pizza Hut offers some of our favorite classic pies like extra cheese and pepperoni with that perfect topping-to-crust ratio, and some great fried cheese sticks, too. But they also have those Cinnabon rolls if you’re looking for something sweet to finish your meal. You can check their deals and place an order for pickup to feed the whole family without breaking the bank.
Pizzano’s Pizza and Grinderz
$ | (863) 386-1045 | WEBSITE
Pizzano’s Pizza and Grinderz is a cozy spot in the heart of a plaza, offering a variety of tasty options. The pizza is a standout, known for its delicious taste and plentiful ingredients. Many customers praise the food for being amazing and fresh, with some noting that the flavors are so authentic they make toes wiggle while eating. The restaurant also offers vegetarian options like veggie pizza and eggplant subs, along with steak, cheese, and mushroom grinders that come highly recommended.
The owner is friendly, and the service is good, with food ready as promised. The atmosphere is welcoming and kid-friendly, featuring seating and video games along the wall, making it a popular spot for locals and families. While some experiences vary, overall, it is a great place to enjoy a tasteful meal and friendly conversation.
the 301
$ | (863) 873-4725 | WEBSITE
The 301 has three standout dishes available for order this evening, but this Sebring restaurant and bar is putting their own creative spin on each. Their flatbread gets some added richness from beer cheese and a topping of fresh herbs, while their burger is perfectly cooked and comes with house-made pickles. And if you want some classic pub fare with a twist, they also have their signature pretzel with beer cheese available.
The friendly staff like Kristina and Katie are always ready with cocktail recommendations, including their new favorite, the John Daley with sweet tea. With local brews on tap and house-distilled liquors like fresh watermelon vodka, The 301 offers a fun vibe and great service that makes it worth checking out if you’re in the area.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (863) 471-3030 | WEBSITE
This reliable Sebring pizza spot only has one standout item in their regular rotation, but it has so much going on, one pizza is probably all you need. It’s the ultimate combination pie: fresh mozzarella and pepperoni baked into a crispy crust, topped with mushrooms, green peppers, and their signature garlic sauce. If this sounds like a satisfying meal rather than something that’ll leave you waiting around, you can place your order online.
Hungry Howie’s Pizza & Subs
$ | (863) 385-4777 | WEBSITE
Hungry Howie’s Pizza & Subs in Sebring makes great pizza, but this New Year’s Eve they’ll also have baked pasta. You can get their holiday special which comes with both a pepperoni pizza and a meatball pasta bake. Orders for delivery can be placed online.
Zack’s Pizza & Bbq
$ | (863) 659-1629 | WEBSITE
As much as we wish we could have Zack’s New York-style pizza as our go-to Friday night dinner, they’re closed. But even though we can’t visit this great pizza spot on the weekend, they do have a variety of wings available for delivery, like hot sauce and mango habanero. And though it’s not pizza, we’re pretty sure if you show up with a box of their garlic rolls no one’s going to complain.
Galati’s Family Restaurant
$ | (863) 382-3333 | WEBSITE
Galati’s Family Restaurant, now operating as Big Italy, offers a welcoming Italian dining experience complete with Turkish coffee, friendly service, and classic pasta dishes. But if all you want is pizza with exceptional flavor and crust, they have the ‘big special’ piled high with a surprising amount of toppings, plus wings and ravioli that are widely praised. The cozy back room adds to the charm, and there’s convenient parking both in front and in back.
Guests appreciate the warm atmosphere and sense of community that makes Big Italy a great place to sit, relax, and enjoy a meal.
Papa Johns Pizza
$ | (863) 386-1177 | WEBSITE
Pizza, Pizza My Darling, is a great New York style pizza spot in Sebring with three popular choices for the family: pepperoni, cheese, and sausage. Click here to place your order.
Little Italy Restaurant
$ | (863) 452-2000 | WEBSITE
Little Italy Restaurant is home to our favorite pizza in Highlands County, along with other great Italian classics like calzones and dishes with anchovies. Basically, anything that comes out of their kitchen is delicious—family dinners included. Head over to their Sebring location to try varieties like their signature pizza and maybe throw in a calzone. Dining is available in their clean indoor space or their perfect outdoor seating area.
Market 27
$ | (863) 784-0489 | WEBSITE
Market 27 will be serving up three standout dishes this holiday season: their signature loaded pizza, the classic cheeseburger platter, and the legendary macaroni and cheese. If you want to indulge in one or all three for your gathering (plus maybe a scoop or two from their famous ice cream bar), they’re welcoming orders until December 31.
Little Caesars Pizza
$ | (863) 471-0220 | WEBSITE
Stop by Little Caesars Pizza in Sebring if you’re looking for a quick and affordable meal for the whole family. They offer a variety of pizza options from classic pepperoni to specialty combinations, as well as wings and breadsticks. The staff is generally helpful, though you might encounter occasional technical issues with their payment systems. It’s a reliable choice when you need something fast that both adults and kids will enjoy.