Maybe you’re a weary traveler craving a slice of comfort after a long day on I-96. Maybe you’re a local who’s tired of the same old chain delivery. Maybe you just need a reason to gather friends around a table without pretense. Whatever brings you here, Wyoming, MI’s pizza scene offers more than just dough and cheese—it offers connection. Let’s explore where to find it.
Joe’s Pizza King
$ | (616) 534-8808 | WEBSITE
Joe’s Pizza King’s cozy dining area in Wyoming is absolutely welcoming to settle into, and that alone makes it a family dinner favorite in this part of town. Yes, it’s simple and unpretentious, and the straightforward pizza menu is filled entirely with dishes you’ll crave again in two days, but if you’re looking to satisfy a hungry family or absolutely delight a group of friends after a concert, keep Joe’s Pizza King on your shortlist.
Pizza Hut
$ | (616) 249-9499 | WEBSITE
You’ve been told to try the “best pizza in Wyoming” by someone whose actual cooking skills are questionable, but who is “craving something reliable” and has decided they want to share that craving with you. They’ve already made Pizza Hut their unofficial go-to (their kitchen is their official one), so you might as well join them there. The staff are wearing polo shirts, there’s the scent of baked dough on almost every surface, and everyone is eating pizza at 6:30pm on a Sunday. Including you.
Hungry Howie’s Pizza
$ | (616) 249-7070 | WEBSITE
Not every Wyoming pizza night has to mean soggy crusts and skimpy toppings. Hungry Howie’s Pizza is a local staple, and its varied pizza experience is exactly what you need when you and your friends want to settle in with a hot, fresh pie loaded with generous toppings. Its Wyoming location certainly means you’re getting that classic neighborhood delivery, so it’s important to remember that timing matters—sometimes they leave pizzas outside in the cold, which can affect your enjoyment.
Roberto’s Pizza
$ | (616) 245-1800 | WEBSITE
If your family craves a reliable pizza night, they probably have Roberto’s on their speed dial. But you can satisfy anyone here with a taste of Michigan comfort (even though this Wyoming spot technically opened years ago.) You’ll see parents sharing crust-dipping tips with their kids, your neighbor enjoying a fresh sub while reading the paper, and regulars happily digging into taco salads during a busy lunch hour.
Whoever you bring here will surely feel at home in the midst of it all, and the food happens to be pretty delicious, from praised pizzas with that crusty dough and special sauce to fresh salads and great subs.
Palermo Pizza (at Gezon) is now Faro’s Pizza
$ | (616) 531-8300 | WEBSITE
This cozy pizza joint in Wyoming, MI is as unpretentious and welcoming as the Italian family that runs it, but still delivers genuine quality as a reliable neighborhood spot.
The homemade sauce with its standout flavor makes the pizza taste like a nonna’s kitchen, the service is excellent with staff like Jay going above and beyond, and some menu items are truly memorable, such as the must-try meatballs bursting with authentic seasoning and the unique option to have toppings tucked under the cheese that creates a delightful surprise. Expect to keep it affordable because you’re not leaving here without feeling satisfied for under $40 for two.
Lombardo’s Pizza of Wyoming
$ | (616) 534-5600 | WEBSITE
If you’re in the business of authentic, cheesy, and flavorful pizzas that beat the chain restaurants, you probably crave the kind of generous portions and real ingredients that make a meal memorable. Lombardo’s Pizza of Wyoming is the perfect spot for these pizza lovers, with a straightforward, welcoming atmosphere and a tasty menu where everything delivers on flavor.
Expect regulars grabbing their go-to orders, friendly service, and delicious options, like their amazing pizzas with that unique crust unlike any other, tasty subs with authentic sausage, and their famous Italian cheese bread with that praised ranch dressing on the side.
Villa Mia Pizza 36th
$$ | (616) 531-7371 | WEBSITE
You’ve likely stopped by this reliable pizza spot in Wyoming for a quick family dinner or maybe a casual weeknight meal, but Villa Mia Pizza 36th might actually shine brightest at lunch. The 36th Street location is convenient with parking in the back, and the menu is packed with pizza (the classic pie with its crispy crust is essential), pasta, and satisfying subs. Oh, and the most expensive item is $16.
Palermo Pizza
$ | (616) 538-0621 | WEBSITE
Your quest for the best pizza in Wyoming is almost complete and a craving is showing interest. Go satisfy it at Palermo Pizza. The local staple is still nearly impossible to get a seat during the dinner rush, but at lunch, you can easily get a table or even just walk in. The menu is largely the same as all day, filled with every classic slice, deluxe sub, or pizza you and your soon-to-be-satisfied appetite could want.
Also, the friendly atmosphere is even better when the staff has a moment to chat.
Andiamo’s Pizza
$ | (616) 249-7773 | WEBSITE
Andiamo’s Pizza in the Grand Rapids area is about as local as a pizza joint can get. Almost every order here will involve Chicago-style pies, someone grabbing a calzone to go, and a regular in the corner digging into spaghetti and meatballs. And when you’re trying to convince yourself you’re getting a great deal on hearty food, all that works in your favor.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (616) 538-9300 | WEBSITE
Marco’s Pizza is a neighborhood spot in Wyoming, MI that’s refreshingly straightforward. Its consistent quality and convenient location make it a reliable option for a family dinner, but not the kind that requires planning.
You come here with people you actually enjoy—maybe even your hungry kids—for a relaxed, no-fuss meal full of things you’ve loved for years: their Deluxe pizza with all the toppings, Cheesey bread that’s perfectly gooey, and one of the area’s best cold 2-liter drinks that arrive chilled every time.
The friendly staff gets orders ready exactly when promised, whether you’re picking up or having it delivered, and the easy online system means you can focus on what matters—enjoying food that looks like it came from the pizza gods. With plenty of parking right out front and a welcoming atmosphere that doesn’t try too hard, it’s the kind of place you return to when you just want a satisfying meal without any fuss.
Jet’s Pizza
$ | (616) 261-5387 | WEBSITE
Right in the heart of Wyoming’s pizza scene, Jet’s Pizza is a straightforward spot that’s perfect for a reliably satisfying pizza run. You won’t be the only person grabbing a quick takeout dinner here, but the crowd tends to be loyal regulars rather than folks looking for a fancy night out. They’ve got consistently hot food, a solid selection of pies (the New York style and deep dish Cajun crust are excellent), and prices that are so reasonable you won’t think twice about treating the family.
The pepperoni pizza and buffalo wings are cooked fresh, the breadsticks are just right, and while the dining room can feel a bit chilly, the service is friendly and the whole place is impressively clean. It’s the kind of place where you know exactly what you’re getting: fresh, hot pizza that hits the spot every time.
Monelli’s Italian Grill & Sports Bar
$ | (616) 530-9700 | WEBSITE
It’s your turn to host the visiting team from out of town, and they’re already buzzing about catching the game somewhere fun. Your best bet: Monelli’s Italian Grill & Sports Bar, a.k.a. one of Wyoming’s liveliest sports bars with enough flat screens to make any fan feel right at home. It also helps that the food here is much more satisfying than typical bar fare—prioritize their generous chicken parmesan, classic Italian subs, and pepperoni rolls that should be shared with a group.