Take “pizza” and slap a word after it—voilà, you’ve got yourself a pizza joint in Yonkers. The sheer number of these hyphenated havens is almost comical, making it tough to sift through the contenders. But beneath the familiar labels, each spot carves out its own delicious identity. We’ve sliced through them all to bring you the definitive ranking.
Alfonso’s Pizza
$ | (914) 423-4706 | WEBSITE
This local favorite leans into classics like perfectly thin-crust pizza, and while these slices might not have the dramatic cheese pull some purists crave, you’re coming here for the sweet and spicy wings, a.k.a. the standout at this Yonkers spot. The crispy chicken pieces are coated in that addictive chili glaze, fried up to a satisfying crunch, and served piping hot. Order a whole pie for the table, and do your best to ignore the nearby regulars wearing well-loved Yankees caps.
Raceway Pizza
$ | (914) 326-3016 | WEBSITE
Forget the fancy trattorias—we’re heading to Raceway Pizza for our recreational activities (read: devouring pizza slices by the tray). This unpretentious Yonkers spot serves classic standbys like the chicken/broccoli/tomato slice or the meat lover’s slice, with dough baked to a precise, perfect crisp. It’s cozy inside—just booths, tables, and the kitchen in the back—so save this spot for weeknight dinners or massive takeout orders.
Palisades Pizza & Pasta
$$ | (914) 963-0127 | WEBSITE
Don’t get it confused—Palisades Pizza & Pasta has zero relation to Palisades Pies. But this Yonkers spot is still a great option when your internal clock is in urgent need of a slice. The space is usually filled with neighbors and groups of friends passing boxes and dunking crusts in garlic sauce (the ones here come with that crispy, fresh base, but hold their toppings when you pick them up regardless).
And if you want to watch the entire life cycle of a pizza, stare over at the open kitchen where you can see the whole process in action.
Lezama’s Pizza
$ | (914) 613-8484 | WEBSITE
Arguably the most inviting name on this list, but unfortunately, the least impressive in the pizza category. The signature pizza isn’t far off from what you’d find at a chain spot, but the reason to make a trip here is for the pasta dishes—the penne alla vodka and garlic and oil with broccoli are hits.
Catania’s Pizzeria
$ | (914) 779-5105 | WEBSITE
Catania’s Pizzeria is the gold standard. The blueprint. The undisputed titleholder of all things dough, sauce, and cheese. That’s thanks to their expertly crafted pepperoni pizza, mini calzones packed with meat and cheese fillings, and spaghetti and meatballs that might leave you needing a nap after you take a bite. The Yonkers spot is the definition of reliable—once you sit, you’ll be in and out within 30 minutes. But you’re not here for frills.
You’re here for some of the best pizza in New York.
Sophia’s Pizza & Pasta
$ | (914) 965-6565 | WEBSITE
Sophia’s Pizza & Pasta has been a staple in the Woodlawn/McClean Avenue area for years, and it’s easy to see why. Both the pizza and the lasagna are worth a visit alone—the pizza has a great crust with generous toppings, and the lasagna is flavorful with solid beef. Also try the tres leche cake for dessert, which is a favorite for many regulars. Nothing will blow your mind, but it’s easy to be satisfied by a meal here, especially with the cheerful service and quick delivery, even on busy nights.
Angelo’s Pizzeria
$ | (914) 237-2401 | WEBSITE
The only downside to Angelo’s Pizzeria is the fact that the dining area is fairly compact. It’s the hottest pizza destination in this part of Yonkers, so prepare to wait for a table, or just cave, order your slices to go, and enjoy them fresh from the box at a nearby park. In this case, all the praise does equal quality—these are some of the best pies in the neighborhood.
Do whatever you can to get your hands on the precious Buffalo chicken slice, which arrives piping hot and requires immediate appreciation. It’s savory, addictive as hell, and you should devour it like a treat (that is, after it cools just enough).
Anselmo’s Pizzeria & Deli
$ | (914) 969-1949 | WEBSITE
If the big chain pizzerias are the predictable sedans of the pizza world, then Anselmo’s Pizzeria & Deli is the reliable, well-loved pickup truck. The Yonkers spot has worn wooden booths, checkered tablecloths, and a seemingly perpetual line out the door that makes this place feel like a neighborhood institution. And the pizza follows a similar route: there’s amazing Shrimp Scampi slices and customizable meals that are extra satisfying.
But despite all the crowds, each of these dishes actually deliver on both flavor and value.
Bella Rosa Pizzeria
$$ | (914) 410-3821 | WEBSITE
The Yonkers outpost of this neighborhood pizzeria (they also have another location in the Bronx called, wait for it, Bella Rosa Too) serves almost the exact same menu, so come here when you want the same pizza expertise in a setting that could double as your Italian grandmother’s kitchen—think warm wooden tables, checkered tablecloths, and framed family photos. The way to do things here is to order as many slices as you are years old, and roll yourself out.
Dunwoodie Pizzeria
$ | (914) 476-5008 | WEBSITE
Dunwoodie Pizzeria is a longtime fixture in the Yonkers pizza scene, and they’ve consistently maintained their legendary status. Their massive pepperoni pizza, which crackles with each bite like a symphony of crispy, savory goodness, earns our Crispiest Crust award without question. And the garlic knots are so soft and freshly made, you’ll taste the buttery, garlicky perfection with every pull-apart piece throughout the entire bustling dining room.
Luigi’s Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc.
$ | (914) 776-1251 | WEBSITE
Naturally, lots of the places on this guide hone in on their pizza. But Luigi’s Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc. in Yonkers, like a certain beloved neighborhood joint, is great all around. Their white slice is perfectly balanced and the eggplant parmesan hero has wonderfully savory edges. The entrees are even better. Go for the Penne Broccoli Rabe or the chickpea salad draped in a bright, herby dressing.
Marcellino’s Restaurant & Lounge
$$ | (914) 395-0033 | WEBSITE
When you want top-tier pizza quality without having to spend an hour waiting for a table, Marcellino’s is your sneaky sleeper hit. The relaxed Yonkers spot would be easy to pass by, but you shouldn’t—fantastic jerk chicken and seafood pasta await. The standout is the cavatelli with sausage that tastes like tender pillows of flavorful filling and sauce, but you can’t go wrong with any of the menu options.