We hear the University of Vermont students swear by the dining hall’s mac and cheese, and we’re pretty sure the maple syrup purists on Church Street will glare if you mention pancake mix. But if you’d prefer an easier way to find standout meals in Colchester, use this list for farm-to-table gems, cozy pubs, and more.
Hillis’ Sugarbush Farm & Vineyard
$$ | (802) 893-2928 | WEBSITE
You could have a wonderful visit just tasting Hillis’ wines, but the full farm experience here is worth prioritizing, especially if you come with a few other people. The next time you’re planning a group outing, make the trip to this spot run by Judy and Jim, and explore the Maple Sugar House and stunning gardens together. The small vineyard is always welcoming with people enjoying the organic wines and beautiful surroundings, so be sure to check their seasonal hours before you visit.
Starbucks
$ | (802) 735-8112 | WEBSITE
If the idea of another generic coffee chain experience leaves you uninspired, a stop at Starbucks in Colchester might just change your mind. This accessible coffee shop serves consistently good-quality drinks and food in a cozy environment where the staff’s friendly efficiency shines. The experience—which costs between $4-$8 for most beverages, with some specialty drinks reaching $10—is just as much about the welcoming atmosphere as it is about the caffeine fix.
If you don’t want to commit to a full sit-down visit, you can grab your order to go from the efficient counter service, or enjoy it on their accessible patio with its thoughtful amenities.
Rozzi’s Lakeshore Tavern
$ | (802) 863-2342 | WEBSITE
Rozzi’s comes from the same folks who run the popular weekend brunch spots in town. Except instead of fancy brunch plates, you’ll find classic tavern comfort food, like the Flintstone burger and other options such as the plain Jane burger, tots, and club sandwich. If you’re bringing family who appreciate a laid-back vibe, this is the spot—sit in the separate kids’ area and make sure to order the well-seasoned, tasty dishes.
For a more casual meal out, grab a table in the main dining area with friends or your partner, sharing a round of tots and one of the best-cooked burgers we can remember having in a comfortable, family-friendly setting.
Athens Diner
$ | (802) 655-3455 | WEBSITE
If you’re in Colchester and find yourself craving classic diner fare, Athens Diner is a great option. There aren’t any fancy frills here, but the cozy dining room, which is decorated with retro booths and other vintage touches, is a nice place to sit with a small group and enjoy some quality comfort food. Try the meat skillet, Vermonter corned beef hash skillet, and other hot, well-presented meals that come at fair prices.
Makalu Himalayan Sherpa Restaurant
$ | (802) 497-1902 | WEBSITE
When you need to eat authentic Himalayan food in the sort of no-frills space a family-run spot would maintain for decades, grab a table at Makalu. A Sherpa restaurant known for its consistently excellent meals, this is a warm place with fading decor, friendly service, and food that’s just as satisfying as the atmosphere. Try some lamb, or grab a plate of momos. Keep in mind, everything here is also reasonably priced and perfect for a quick meal.
Zachary’s
$ | (802) 862-7900 | WEBSITE
This Italian family spot is from the people behind the local chain, and it’s just as reliable. Their standout burger easily ranks among the town’s top comfort foods, and the hearty lasagna is exactly what you need after a long winter day. Unlike some locations, this Zachary’s doesn’t actually have a game room (it’s a smaller space), but it has ample seating and a friendly atmosphere where you can relax with the kids.
The chicken bacon ranch pizza hits the spot every time, and the prompt service keeps things moving even when the dining room fills up. At about $15-20 per entree, you get good value for those generous portions. The warm lighting and simple wooden tables make it feel like a neighborhood staple rather than anything fancy. Overall, Zachary’s delivers exactly what it promises: satisfying, no-frills Italian food in a welcoming setting that families keep coming back to.
The Pickled Perch
$$ | (802) 497-1647 | WEBSITE
Life is about finding reliable spots, and this place delivers. The Pickled Perch is a local favorite that works for many occasions: a casual lunch after errands, dinner with family, or drinks with friends after work. Service is friendly, the atmosphere is inviting with warm lighting and comfortable booths, and there’s shaded parking for those sunny Vermont afternoons.
When you need a dependable meal in Colchester, just head here and enjoy a grilled chicken sandwich with side salad, some shrimp tacos, or a delicious bacon cheeseburger. Don’t skip the apple pie cheesecake—it’s one of the best desserts around.
New York Pizza Oven
$ | (802) 658-0925 | WEBSITE
There used to be a lot of pizza joints in Colchester, but New York Pizza Oven is one of the few solid options remaining. This place is cozy, bright, and casual, and it’s perfect for a family night when you want to share some garlic knots and boneless chicken while catching up on the week. The pizza is good but a bit crunchy, and while some dishes can be overcooked, the fresh appetizers, subs, and wings keep things interesting.
On weekends, it’s bustling with friendly staff and reliable delivery, making it a spot worth trying again.
Casa Real, Mexican Restaurant
$ | (802) 495-5952 | WEBSITE
You’ve probably heard of Casa Real. There are currently a few locations around the area, but the original is in Colchester, and it tends to stay busy—because this place serves some of the best Mexican food in Vermont. There are plenty of options to choose from (including delicious margaritas), and we tend to gravitate toward the birria. No matter what you get, it’ll come out quickly on your table.
There’s extensive dining space at this welcoming restaurant, but you can always use the separate takeout area if you prefer.
Three Brothers Pizza & Grill
$ | (802) 655-5550 | WEBSITE
Three Brothers Pizza & Grill (from the same folks who brought you that cozy spot everyone keeps talking about) makes a slightly different style of pizza than what you might find at other pizza joints around town. Instead of being overloaded with toppings, the Pizza a la Vodka is crafted with a crispy crust, plenty of cheese and herbs, then finished with a robust sauce that has just the right kick.
The result is as perfect for a casual weeknight dinner as it is for a get-together that might result in empty plates and a spontaneous decision to order another round of that phenomenal Champ pizza.
Burger Bar
$ | (802) 448-3657 | WEBSITE
Burger Bar is a must-visit spot in Colchester known for its excellent food and service. The name reflects its straightforward focus on burgers, but the menu offers plenty of customization, like having them lettuce wrapped for a lighter option. For a handy tutorial on what to expect, start your meal with the Hot Hamburg with gravy, a hearty classic that pairs perfectly with crispy onion rings and French fries.
Bring a group, and enjoy a fun atmosphere in the casual dining room with board games available for both kids and adults. The accommodating staff, including Lizzie, who is highlighted for her attentiveness and kindness, makes the experience even better. While there might be a small extra charge for lettuce wrapping, the quality of the food, including the great wings, makes up for it.
Burger Bar offers great value for a pleasant dining experience, whether for eating in or taking out, and it comes highly recommended, especially for those near Essex.